Buy-to-let beats gold, cash and fine art for investment returns in the last decade

March 20, 2019

Research by VeriSmart, the UK’s only combined lettings inventory and property compliance specialists, has looked at just how lucrative the UK buy-to-let market has been in the 10 years since the financial crisis when compared to other investment options like the FTSE 100, classic cars, gold and fine art.

VeriSmart looked at the return on each investment and how each market has performed over the last 10 years with the research showing that buy-to-let property is up there with the FTSE 100 and classic cars when it comes to a sound investment.

Investing in the FTSE 100 would have brought the biggest return when considering the annual capital gain and the percentage yield with an increase of 119%, whilst the value of classic cars is up 94% during the same time period.

However, for those that aren’t professional investors or that don’t have the garage space for a fleet of classic cars, a buy-to-let property is a very good ‘next best option’ and, when considering the annual gain in house prices along with the increase in rental yields, an investment in the sector a decade ago would have brought a 92% return today.

This is much higher than the 60% return that investing in gold would have brought and a world away from the 16% increase in cash or the -4% drop in fine art.

It’s also important to note that the growth in the property market has been by far the most reliable option with the FTSE 100, gold or cash providing a far more volatile option that is also open to a larger degree of impact from political and economic factors as well as influence from other foreign countries.

While classic car investment sits ahead of property, that too is made or broken on the car itself rather than the overall market and while a nice art collection may brighten your walls, it is also harder to find a buyer for – even when compared to the current Brexit property market slowdown.

All things considered and despite successive Chancellors hitting the buy-to-let sector with numerous legislative penalties including an increase in stamp duty, a reduction in high rate tax relief for landlords and a higher rate of capital gains tax on residential property profits, UK bricks and mortar remains one of the best and most stable investments available.

Founder of VeriSmart, Jonathan Senior, commented:

“Last week’s spring statement was a missed opportunity for the Government to backtrack on their previous attacks on the buy-to-let sector, attacks that have done little to solve the UK housing crisis and if anything, have caused further restrictions in the level of suitable stock while keeping rental prices buoyant as a result.

However, the buy-to-let sector remains the backbone of the UK property market, helping to support aspirational homeowners as they work to overcome the sometimes impossible financial barriers of homeownership. The need for this support is clearly evident as it remains one of the most lucrative investments one can make.

With little being done to address property supply or affordability on a meaningful scale, this is likely to continue going forward and despite the Government’s best efforts there will always be demand for a good, honest landlord providing above the board accommodation to those that need it.”

Year
10 Year Gain
 
FTSE 100
119%
Classic Cars
94%
Buy-to-Let
92%
Gold
60%
Cash
16%
Art
-4%
FTSE 100
Year
FTSE 100 Index
Annual Capital Gain
% Yield (Dividend)
% Total FTSE 100 Gain
2009
4147
–
–
–
2010
5302
27.85
3.01
31
2011
5881
10.92
3.62
15
2012
5733
-2.52
3.72
1
2013
6089
6.21
3.46
10
2014
6739
10.67
3.54
14
2015
6501
-3.53
3.98
0
2016
5804
-10.72
3.65
-7
2017
7337
26.41
3.81
30
2018
7730
5.36
4.01
9
Total 10 Year Gain
86.4
32.8
119
Source: FTSE 100 Index
 
Classic Cars
 
Year
Classic Cars
% Total Classic Car Gain
2009
£1,003,733
–
2010
£1,061,562
6
2011
£1,139,465
7
2012
£1,233,351
8
2013
£1,465,975
19
2014
£1,746,184
19
2015
£1,907,475
9
2016
£1,960,490
3
2017
£1,938,526
-1
2018
£1,945,429
0
Total 10 Year Gain
94
 
Source: K500 Index
 
Buy-to-Let
Year
Property value
Annual Capital Gain
% Yield (Rental) Gross
% Total Property Gain
2009
£157,234
–
5.06
5
2010
£167,469
6.51
4.84
11
2011
£167,300
-0.1
4.97
5
2012
£165,908
-0.83
5.14
4
2013
£167,716
1.09
5.05
6
2014
£178,182
6.24
5.14
11
2015
£190,665
7.01
4.88
12
2016
£205,462
7.76
4.66
12
2017
£215,084
4.68
4.64
9
2018
£224,425
4.34
4.47
9
Total 10 Year Gain
42.73
48.86
92
Source: Land Registry
 
Gold
 
Year
Gold per oz
% Total Gold Gain
 
2009
£602.00
–
2010
£693.00
15
2011
£859.00
24
2012
£1,045.00
22
2013
£1,052.00
1
2014
£759.00
-28
2015
£823.00
8
2016
£763.00
-7
2017
£985.00
29
2018
£962.00
-2
Total 10 Year Gain
60
 
Source: Gold.co.uk
 
Cash
 
Year
% Gross Annual Yield on Cash*
 
2009
–
2010
3
2011
3
2012
3
2013
2
2014
1
2015
1
2016
1
2017
1
2018
1
Total 10 Year Gain
16
 
Art
 
Year
Art Index
% Total Art Gain
 
2009
160
–
2010
181
13
2011
208
15
2012
193
-7
2013
194
1
2014
196
1
2015
201
3
2016
153
-24
2017
152
-1
2018
154
1
Total 10 Year Gain
-4
 
Source: ArtPrice
 

 

Properganda PR

National and local media coverage for property businesses. Journo quotes delivered in minutes.

You May Also Enjoy

Breaking News

Council funding to crack down on rogue landlords

English councils are set to receive additional funding and training to help tackle rogue landlords, ahead of taking on new responsibilities when renters’ rights reforms come into force next month. All 317 local authorities in England will share £41 million in funding, building on an earlier £18 million allocation made last autumn. The funding is…
Read More →
New Builds 2020
Breaking News

Fewer than 1 in 5 new properties securing buyer

New-build demand remains subdued as fewer than 1 in 5 homes find buyers in Q1 2026 The latest New-Build Stock and Demand Index from Property Inspect has found that demand for new-build homes remained subdued in the first quarter of 2026, with fewer than one in five new properties securing a buyer. New-build stock levels…
Read More →
Estate Agent Talk

Top five AML red flags in UK property transactions

Cash-heavy and internationally supported purchases continue to shape the UK market New data from client due diligence platform Thirdfort reveals the most common anti-money laundering (AML) red flags identified in UK property transactions. Analysis of more than 415,000 completed Source of Funds (SoF) checks shows that the top five red flags are: Savings mismatch – 43.04% Gifted…
Read More →
Estate Agent Talk

Discover Northern Ireland’s top emerging investment hotspots

Derry/ Londonderry and Fermanagh named Northern Ireland’s top emerging investment hotspots Northern Ireland’s emerging investment hotspots are delivering compelling opportunities for landlords in 2026, with new research from Belfast-based estate agency John Minnis revealing a shift in where investors are finding the strongest returns. Drawing on insights from the latest John Minnis Investment Guide, the…
Read More →
Breaking News

Breaking Property News 13/4/26

Daily bite-sized proptech and property news in partnership with Proptech-X.   Why customisation matters more than capability Thought Leadership by Wes Snow CEO & Co-founder of Ascendix Technologies ‘There’s a persistent misconception that success with Artificial Intelligence comes down to selecting the most advanced or sophisticated tool. In reality, that’s not where the value lies. The real…
Read More →
Rightmove logo
Breaking News

First-time buyers pay extra £307m in stamp duty since relief ended

New Rightmove analysis reveals that since the end of the temporary relief measure in April 2025, first-time buyers in England have paid an estimated £307 million extra in stamp duty, averaging £4,618 more per buyer: The total estimated first-time buyer stamp duty bill over the past year was £408 million, versus £101 million the previous year In April 2025 the first-time buyer stamp duty threshold was lowered from £425,000 to £300,000. Before the change 62% of homes for sale were stamp-duty free for first-time buyers and that has…
Read More →