Modular housing can’t solve the housing crisis

Quick ways to add value to your property

Whether building modular, offsite or traditional, you cannot start building unless you have planning permission.

Modular housing is often championed as the silver bullet solution to the housing crisis. Built more quickly in factories and quality-controlled before assembly, there are some clear positives to building modular. However, at this stage, modular housing will not and cannot solve the housing crisis.

Britain has enough building capacity to meet the Government’s ambition of 300,000 homes new homes every year, but it doesn’t have a planning system that allows for those homes to be built.

Whether building modular, offsite or traditional, you cannot start building unless you have planning permission.

Many commentators highlight that developers are sitting on more than 420,000 unbuilt planning permissions, but they don’t present the whole picture. A large majority are not full planning permissions and they are either unviable, due to landowners underestimating costs, or stuck because of outstanding pre-commencement conditions and negotiable contributions such as section 106 agreements.

Many of these permissions are also for phased development, which can see a large site take more than a decade to complete.

The real reason we cannot solve the housing crisis is because the planning process is unfit to solve it.

Local plans, which allocate sites for housing, often focus on large and slow-to-deliver sites, requiring heavy infrastructure investment to be made uncontroversial. Despite being vital to meeting demand, relying primarily on large sites outside existing communities is not getting the right homes built in the right places.

To remedy this, in 2016 the industry put forward the idea of a small sites register, which would get more small and infill sites within existing communities delivered first. Local authorities rejected the proposal, citing a lack of resources.

The development industry responded by accepting a 20% increase in planning fees, provided the revenue went back into planning departments.

Yet, in 2018, when the development industry welcomed the Government’s proposal of 20% of sites in local plans being small or medium sized and the HBA recommended 30%, local authorities convinced the Government to lower the figure, which was amended to 10%.

Other measures to encourage diversification of sites and opportunity have also failed, with the self-build register barely delivering any homes and the brownfield register completely underwhelming. In West Dorset, Weymouth and Portland, the CPRE reports that only a third of the 2,600 brownfield sites have planning applications, with very few being allocated in the local plan.

Allocations have become so weighted against small sites that the average site size has increased by 17% in less than a decade.

But allocations are not the only problem. The planning process itself is expensive, slow and unfit for purpose. Around 42% of minor residential planning applications and 75% of major are subject to extension of time requests, environmental impact assessments or performance agreements. This means that the 13 week statutory period for planning applications often increases to six months or, in some cases, years.

The Government has often championed more lending as a solution, but money cannot be drawn down unless planning is secured. This has become such a problem that Homes England, the Government’s housing arm, is making efforts to secure planning permissions for developers so they can access funding.

Developers are also tired of providing pre-commencement information (e.g. landscaping, material schedules or archaeological surveys) at the start of applications only to have them conditioned, which involves a charge and sign off process by local planners that can take weeks or months.

As one member commented ”When it takes three years to get planning for fifteen homes but six months for 300, there is clearly a problem.”

The industry has always been sympathetic to resource-stretched planning departments, who need more funding. However, the housing crisis exists because the planning process rejects the right homes in the right places. Modular housing cannot fix the housing crisis, only planning reform can. Unless planning reform is the focus of the conversation, we won’t need 300,000 new homes to meet demand in two years, we will need 540,000.

Words by Rico Wojtulewicz, head of housing and planning policy at the House Builders Association – the house building division of the National Federation of Builders.

National Federation of Builders

The National Federation of Builders is a United Kingdom trade association representing the interests of small and medium-sized building contractors in England and Wales.

You May Also Enjoy

Breaking News

Christmas rental voids jumps by almost 40%

Cost of Christmas rental voids jumps by almost 40% as landlords face £1,350 income shortfall   The cost of an empty rental property has risen by 38.6% in the last year, with landlords in England now facing an estimated £1,350 in lost rental income during a typical void period, up £376 compared with last Christmas…
Read More →
Breaking News

UK property transactions forecast to fall 4.4% in 2026

The latest property market forecast from eXp UK suggests that residential transactions across the UK are on course to fall by 4.4% in 2026, with market activity expected to finish below last year’s levels before rebounding by 6.7% in 2027. eXp UK analysed quarterly property transaction trends across England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland dating…
Read More →
Breaking News

London renters paying £1,000 more a year in rent

The latest research by London lettings and estate agent, Benham and Reeves, has revealed that the average annual cost of renting in London has climbed by almost £1,000 over the last year, with 11 boroughs seeing increases of more than £1,000 and two recording hikes in excess of £2,000. Benham and Reeves analysed the latest…
Read More →
Breaking News

UK Inflation Hits 3.6%: What Rising Prices Mean for House Prices

UK inflation rose to 3.6% in October, sparking cautious concern across the property and mortgage sectors. With price pressures holding firm, industry leaders warn that further Bank of England base rate hikes remain on the table, dashing hopes of any immediate relief on high fixed-rate mortgage deals for buyers and landlords.   Nathan Emerson, CEO…
Read More →
Breaking News

Average UK Property Value Hits £273,000 Despite Monthly Dip in September

UK House Price Index Summary for September 2026 The average monthly rate of house price growth in September declined slightly to -0.5%. The average annual rate of house price growth in September was up +1.2%. As a result, the average UK house price is now £273,000.   Thoughts from the Industry:   Director of Benham and…
Read More →
Breaking News

UK Rents Hit £1,411 as House Prices Edge Up 1.2%

Average UK monthly private rent increased by 3.8%, to £1,411, in the 12 months to October 2026 (provisional estimate); this annual growth rate is unchanged from the 12 months to September 2026. Average rents increased to £1,472 (4.0%) in England, £849 (3.9%) in Wales, and £1,015 (0.7%) in Scotland, in the 12 months to October…
Read More →