Are online-only agents just FSBO in disguise?

The Real Estate Pundit writes primarily about Property Technology: https://twitter.com/realpundit

And there it is: the deafening chorus of traditional estate agents screaming “Yes!”.

For years high street agents have been crying foul that Rightmove allows For-Sale-By-Owner sites to sneak listings next to theirs.

But with the barrier to entry for a new estate agent so low, alongside relatively low commissions in the UK (1-1.5% vs 5-6% in the rest of the world), is there no small amount of hypocrisy in the claim online-agents are undermining the industry?

It seems that only Foxtons doesn’t negotiate their fee, while most other agents will happily come down to 1% in the current race to the bottom on agency fees.

And this decreased income has brought about its own evil: double charging.

But first, we have to understand the term ‘agent’. An agent is proxy for the owner (or buyer, if the agent represents the other side). They are giving expertise and time to do some work on behalf of the owner. Naturally agents charge a fee for their proxy representation. That fee includes marketing costs, vetting of buyers (or tenants) and generally chasing loose ends.

The core premise of an online agent is that Rightmove exists and does the vast majority of the hard work. Traditional agents argue that Rightmove wouldn’t exist without all their collective listings data, but that point is now moot (even in light of the rise of Agents’ Mutual).

So, if an online-only agent charges for access to Rightmove, and has a menu of items you can pay for, like ‘For Sale’ boards and conducting viewings, are they really an agent?

Rightmove judge an agent to be a company that abides by regulatory standards (which are a bit of a joke) and that all communication should not go directly to the owner.

And there you have it: answer the call before transferring buyer/tenant leads to the owner, and pay a small fee to The Property Ombudsman.

So you can see the point made by High Street Agents: online agents aren’t agents at all.

However, do traditional agents see their own hypocrisy when they charge both landlord and tenant for referencing? Or worse, add an uplift fee on maintenance works to landlords who pay a monthly management agency fee.

It is these practices that continue to tarnish the industry. And it is that tarnish that leads to ‘disruptors’ coming in to try and steal customers and market share.

Agents’ Mutual has gained so much support as a counter-measure; we’ll be hearing that 4,000 branches have signed up to OnTheMarket.com any day now, as a battle cry.

There has been a recent surge of new online-only agencies to join the stalwarts of eMoov, Hatched and HouseSimple. Known brands like EasyGroup and Sarah Beeny have been getting in on the act with the predictable and oddly named EasyProperty and Tepilo.

Will any online-only agent convert property owners to their new low-cost religion? In a nation famous for an aversion to bartering, it is highly unlikely.

Alex Evans

You May Also Enjoy

Breaking News

Popping the Asking Price Bubble

Where in the Uk Can Buyers Snap Up Property Bargains and Where Properties Go for a Premium Above Asking Price   New research from fast selling property company, Upstix has uncovered the UK’s most surprising postcodes for snapping up a property at bargain prices this year, highlighting a widening gap between sellers’ expectations and the…
Read More
Rightmove logo
Breaking News

Highest demand to lease office space since pre-pandemic

The latest insights from the UK’s number one commercial property website Rightmove, reveals that the number of unique enquiries to lease office space is at its highest point since pre-pandemic, as businesses look for spaces that meet modern requirements. Demand to lease office space is 19% higher than the same period a year ago and…
Read More
Planning disputes on new build land
Estate Agent Talk

Planning consultations for major infrastructure to be streamlined

Robert Bruce, a planning and infrastructure partner at law firm Freeths LLP, said he: “Welcomed the change as a significant step to speeding up the DCO process and the focus on the quality and effectiveness of the consultation, rather than box ticking and a risk averse approach to pre-application consultation due to the current legal…
Read More
Breaking News

‘The property ladder pulls further away’ warns Open Property Group

For many first-time buyers across England, the dream of homeownership continues to slip further out of reach. Despite rising wages, soaring house prices are making it harder than ever to get on the property ladder. A leading UK professional house buying company ‘Open Property Group’ based in Buckinghamshire UK, has raised concerns over the ongoing…
Read More
Estate Agent Talk

How Long It Takes to Buy a House in the UK: 5 Common Delays That Can Slow Down Your Home Purchase

Wondering how long it takes to buy a house in the UK? The average timeline ranges from 8 to 22 weeks, but even that can stretch significantly due to unexpected delays, especially if you’re a first-time buyer or caught in a chain. That’s why working with experienced professionals like Belvoir — one of the UK’s…
Read More
Love or Hate Rightmove
Breaking News

Rightmove to host Renters’ Rights Bill webinar with Guild of Lettings

Rightmove is hosting a live and interactive webinar session with the Guild of Lettings to help agents get Renters’ Rights Ready. The webinar will take place from 10:00am – 11:00am on Wednesday 23rd April. Susie Crolla, Managing Director for the Guild of Lettings, will be joining Rightmove to help agents with questions they may have about…
Read More