Competition Appeal Tribunal issues judgment in favour of Agents’ Mutual

The Competition Appeal Tribunal today issued its judgment in the case between Agents’ Mutual v Gascoigne Halman.

Ian Springett, Chief Executive of OnTheMarket.com, said: “We are pleased that the Tribunal has confirmed the position maintained consistently by our Board that Agents’ Mutual’s strategy for entry to the portals market has been pro-competitive both in object and effect and that the business is operating within the law. The Tribunal has dismissed the challenge from Gascoigne Halman that Agents’ Mutual and its Members have behaved illegally or anti-competitively.
“All of the key terms of our listing agreements with agents and our membership eligibility rules have been upheld.

“The proceedings before the Tribunal have been running since July last year with the Trial completing in February. The manner in which our opponents conducted the case has caused us to divert considerable resources and management time, as was presumably intended by those, including Zoopla, who funded it.

“The full judgment is lengthy and complex but its conclusions are clear. We will now work with our legal team to recover costs and losses we have incurred as well as deposit monies lodged by us in Court to cover the position had the competition law case been lost.

“A residual, non-competition law element of the case against Gascoigne Halman is still to be completed.

“In the immediate term, we will be ramping up our marketing activity to restore the strong growth in consumer traffic and leads OnTheMarket.com was delivering over its first two years of operations.

“Looking further ahead, the Board has been working over the last few months on substantial new plans which will support the further development of OnTheMarket.com. These plans are well advanced but could not be finalised pending the outcome of the litigation. We will shortly be ready to share them with our Member firms. Our aim is to gain Members’ support for the new plans and be in a position to implement them from the end of August.

“The two largest incumbent portals continue to use agents’ hard-won property listings and their ever-increasing fees to generate super profits for their shareholders at the expense of their agent customers and they are defending their duopoly position vigorously. However, with an excellent online platform, the sustained support of thousands of high quality agents and a highly experienced team, OnTheMarket.com is well positioned to create a genuine alternative market-leading portal for agents and consumers alike.”

Written by vikki.bennett@agentsmutual.co.uk

EAN Content

Content shared by this account is either news shared free by third parties or sponsored (paid for) content from third parties. Please be advised that links to third party websites are not endorsed by Estate Agent Networking - Please do your own research before committing to any third party business promoted on our website. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

You May Also Enjoy

Breaking News

Rent Increases Under Review: What Landlords Need to Know

By Allison Thompson, National Lettings Managing Director, Leaders The Renters’ Rights Bill is currently moving through the House of Lords and is expected to bring wide-ranging changes to the way privately rented homes are managed. Among the most significant are new limits on how and when landlords can increase rent. These reforms aim to improve…
Read More
Breaking News

Breaking Property News 9/09/25

Daily bite-sized proptech and property news in partnership with Proptech-X.   Why those who adopt AI responsibly stand to unlock efficiency, trust, and long-term relevance Artificial intelligence is no longer a distant promise—it is a practical tool transforming how the UK property market operates. From agencies and developers to investors and property managers, it has…
Read More
Breaking News

Industry reacts as Renters’ Rights Bill set to become law

The Renters’ Rights Bill has cleared its final stage in the Commons with Housing Minister Matthew Pennycook confirming that the Government has rejected almost all amendments proposed by the House of Lords. The legislation is now set to proceed through its final ‘ping-pong’ stage before receiving Royal Assent, with all of its major measures intact…
Read More
Home and Living

We asked housemates what really matters when living together

Finding a new houseshare can feel like a gamble. Will it be the warm, welcoming home of your dreams, or the kind of place you actively avoid until bedtime? With so many variables at play, what should you actually be looking for when viewing a co-living house, and what questions are worth asking the current…
Read More
Estate Agent Talk

The Rise of DIY Law: 8 Disputes Brits Are Handling Without Solicitors

A new study by South East law firm, Stephen Rimmer, has raised concern over the number of people attempting to handle legal disputes without professional help, often unaware of the costly risks involved. By analysing UK Google search activity from the past 12 months, the research uncovered the eight areas of dispute law most commonly…
Read More
estate agency contracts
Estate Agent Talk

Homebuyers demand transparency when referred to estate agents

The latest research from GetAgent Exchange has revealed that while referrals to estate agents are now commonplace in the home moving process, buyers and sellers want these referrals to come with transparent data and comparison options, not simply a single recommendation. The survey of more than 1,000 recent homebuyers found that 90% had been referred…
Read More