Farmers protest outside Westminster today in anger at the IHT ongoing debate – expert legal view

With today’s news about farmers set to protest outside Westminster in anger at the IHT ongoing debate, Tom Gauterin, Director at national law firm Freeths, said:

“Although it is good to hear Mr Reed last week suggest that the Government is listening to farmers, today’s protests would suggest otherwise with the extent of their concerns yet to be fully understood. As the entire cost of APR is around £400m, this represents barely 2% of the ‘black hole’. It also seems to underplay the extent to which farmers are themselves (very hard!) ‘working people’.

“If the Government’s aim was to prevent wealthy individuals buying up farmland as an IHT strategy, it might instead have looked at abolishing APR for landlords, rather than imposing it on working farmers. As is widely known, farmers rarely make significant a significant profit – or even any profit – and are constantly at the mercy of natural factors beyond their control. The current proposals seem not to take account of this. By way of example – if a farmer and his wife own a farm worth £5million, of which (say) £500,000 is the value of the farmhouse, this would mean they are farming (at a ballpark value of £10,000/acre) around 450 acres of land.

“If that farm was then subject to APR at 20% on the excess over the allowances of the couple (i.e. everything over £1million each, making £2million total), that would give a tax bill of 20% x £3m =£600,000. Even if this was paid in (interest-bearing) instalments over ten years, this means finding an extra £60,000 income every year – which just about every farmer would consider miraculous – or selling 60 acres of land. In my example, that’s around 13% of the farm. As every farmer will also tell you, farming increasingly relies on economies of scale to be viable.

“It’s true that this will not affect smaller farms, but even a good-sized farm of 450 acres (the average farm size in Britain is around 200 acres) is not by any stretch a big agribusiness, or able to generate sufficient extra income to maintain its integrity. Given the relatively low cost of APR to the Exchequer, it would be good to see a proper consultation on this which may help the Government target this better than it seems to be at present and prevent further resentment building up. APR (IHT in general, in fact) needs reform, but the current proposals fail to achieve the government’s aims while also alienating a large part of the farming community.

“I think the issue here is that the government hasn’t understood how thin the margins even quite large farms run on are. The idea of a ‘small family farm’ ignores the reality that even for a farm two or three times that average size, it’s not being run at a large profit, so funding a hefty tax bill is all but impossible without selling some of the land. The government might more easily achieve its aims by reviewing the availability of APR for landlords.”

EAN Breaking News

Breaking News from the team at Estate Agent Networking. Have a new story to share with us? Then please get in contact today! When and where we can we will refer to third party websites with a 'live link back' where news was released first.

You May Also Enjoy

Property for sale
Estate Agent Talk

5 Top Tips for Increasing the Value of Your Home

For some people, buying a home, working on it and then selling it is the primary goal to keep upgrading homes. Whether you choose to re-decorate or re-model the property, a renovation of your home can help to keep the ball rolling towards enabling you to secure a profit on your next house sale. Whilst…
Read More
Breaking News

Sdlt Hike Spurs Record Home Sales by Auction

iamproperty is crediting the recent Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) hike and rising consumer awareness as the reasons behind a record-breaking quarter for Auction. The market conditions led to an 11% increase in the number of iamproperty Auction sales in the first quarter of the year, compared with the same period last year. iamproperty’s Partner…
Read More
Breaking News

Changes to mortgage affordability to support sales as house price growth cools

House price growth has slowed to 1.6 per cent annually, down from 1.9 per cent at the end of 2024, as buyer interest cools and the number of homes for sale continues to expand Buyer demand is one per cent higher than a year ago, while the number of homes for sale is 12 per…
Read More
Love or Hate Rightmove
Breaking News

Rents rise to new record despite boost in supply

The average advertised rent of homes outside of London has risen to a new record this quarter of £1,349 per calendar month (pcm), however it is the smallest increase in rents at this time of year since 2020: London rents also rise by 0.1% (+£3) to a 14th consecutive new record of £2,698 pcm this quarter…
Read More
Breaking News

Size Matters in Planning

The House Builders Association (HBA), the housebuilding division of the National Federation of Builders (NFB) has reignited its campaign for the planning system to adopt five clear site size definitions, replacing the current, arbitrary ones of ‘Minor’ (one to ten homes) and ‘Major’ (ten and above). Richard Beresford, Chief Executive of the NFB, said: “In…
Read More
Breaking News

Popping the Asking Price Bubble

Where in the Uk Can Buyers Snap Up Property Bargains and Where Properties Go for a Premium Above Asking Price   New research from fast selling property company, Upstix has uncovered the UK’s most surprising postcodes for snapping up a property at bargain prices this year, highlighting a widening gap between sellers’ expectations and the…
Read More