Property owners must take heed of Court of Appeal ruling on Japanese knotweed

Daniel Swimer, Head of the Real Estate Litigation team at London Law firm Joelson, has shared his views on the latest Court of Appeal ruling.

Japanese knotweed can prove very costly for landowners and developers. It can cause structural damages to land developments, block drains, grow between slabs of concrete, disrupt brick paving, and overwhelm outbuildings. It’s also difficult to eradicate. The UK Government has estimated that the cost of eradicating it from the UK stands at £2.6 billion.

In this case, the Court of Appeal has upheld an earlier decision which saw the two respondents receive significant compensation for private nuisance following Network Rail’s inaction over the Japanese knotweed that had encroached on their properties.

Nuisance is the legal term for when a landowner does, or omits to do, something on or with their land, which interferes with the use or enjoyment of neighbouring property, or which causes physical damage to neighbouring property.

The Court of Appeal determined that the affected parties in this case could not succeed in a claim for private nuisance merely because of the diminution in the market value of their properties.

They were entitled however to claim for nuisance caused by the encroachment of the Japanese knotweed because it had reduced their ability to enjoy the amenity and utility of their respective properties.

Sir Terence Etherton, Master of the Rolls, stated that the recorder in the earlier decision was wrong in principle to conclude that the presence of knotweed on Network Rail’s land within seven metres of the claimants’ properties was an actionable nuisance “simply because it diminished the market value of the claimants’ respective properties, because of lender caution in such situations”.

The purpose of the tort of nuisance is not to protect the value of property as an investment or financial asset but to protect the land’s intangible amenity value, specifically the landowners’ ability to fully use and enjoy their properties.

This is an important decision which builds upon a recent spate of cases concerning liability in nuisance for Japanese knotweed.  It should also stand as a warning to developers, landowners and local authorities who fail to treat Japanese knotweed seriously.  They may, however, also welcome this decision as it restricts the basis upon which claims can be brought and may potentially limit the financial compensation awarded by courts in the future.

It is likely that as a result of this appeal other landowners affected by Japanese knotweed will come forward with a view to confronting large scale developments and established housing and commercial property sites.

It is therefore imperative that landowners are constantly vigilant of Japanese knotweed, its roots and rhizomes, as it could impose a serious burden and significant costs on neighbouring landowners wishing to develop their land and or eradicate the weed – costs which could, as a result of this ruling, be passed on to the landowner causing the nuisance.

If you find knotweed on your land, you should arrange for it to be surveyed by a specialist contractor as soon as possible and seek legal advice.

Shared by: Tom Mason – tom@je-consulting.co.uk

EAN Content

Content shared by this account is either news shared free by third parties or sponsored (paid for) content from third parties. Please be advised that links to third party websites are not endorsed by Estate Agent Networking - Please do your own research before committing to any third party business promoted on our website. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

You May Also Enjoy

Planning disputes on new build land
Breaking News

Government’s last-minute Planning Bill amendments will tackle blockers and boost growth

The Government has announced several major amendments to the Planning and Infrastructure Bill, which further streamline the planning process. They include reducing the length of consultation, stripping uncooperative councils of the right to make certain decisions, and paring back the impact and ability to raise legal disputes. Richard Beresford, Chief Executive of the National Federation…
Read More
Breaking News

Next budget a “pivotal moment for the property market”

The UK government is due to unveil its next budgetary statement in November, with many rumours circulating on how it’ll affect the property market. While many rumours are circulating among thought leaders and economists, Mitchell Martyn, property expert from Pure Property Finance, a property finance specialist based in the UK, says that this next budget…
Read More
Breaking News

28% Increase in Brits Moving to Australia

The number of people moving to Australia in the summer of 2025 increased by 28% year on year, making it the busiest quarter for Australia-bound movers in recent years. According to data from international movers surveyed through Compare My Move, September 2025 recorded the highest share of moves to Australia for the year, capping off an…
Read More
new build homes colchester essex
Breaking News

New-build transaction volumes fall by 62%

New-build sales volumes fall by 62%, but market improvements are driving accessibility for homebuyers The latest insight from Yopa has found that, whilst average monthly new-build sales volumes are down 62% so far in 2025, new-build homebuyers are benefitting from improvements to market affordability, with mortgage lenders currently introducing a range of new initiatives and…
Read More
Estate Agent Talk

Brits could buy a haunted property without knowing

Buyers in England and Wales could unknowingly purchase a property with a haunted reputation, as sellers aren’t required to disclose it. Homebuyers who are unaware are at risk, as this could lead to privacy concerns, nuisance from visitors and impact property value. Louise Ainley, a qualified conveyancer at licensed conveyancer course provider Access Law Online,…
Read More
Estate Agent Talk

3 ways a new-build could boost your purchasing position

The latest internal data release from award-winning mortgage adviser, Alexander Hall, has revealed that it’s not just younger, first-time buyers taking advantage of new-build benefits to buy one-bed flats. Multiple homebuyer demographics are purchasing at all levels of the property ladder, buoyed by improvements to the mortgage market landscape, which have seen lenders offer greater…
Read More