SMEs need a ‘Medium sized site’ without area thresholds

Planning disputes on new build land
The Government’s ‘Planning Reform Working Paper: Reforming Site Thresholds’ proposes a ‘Medium’ sized site threshold of 10 to 49 homes, a definition which has won considerable plaudits across the small and medium sized (SME) housebuilding industry.
However, the definition also includes a maximum area measurement of 1 hectare area size, which SME housebuilders express as inappropriate because Local Planning Authorities (LPAs) already set locally acceptable density policies and the increasing policy and development requirements on land use, such as drainage, biodiversity, grid, sewerage, active travel, mean sites regularly go over 1 hectare.
The consequence of an area-based threshold means that many SMEs would miss out on the Medium sized site definition, alongside its introduction of planning proportionality.
Michael Parinchy, Construction Manager at ProBuild 360 Ltd and HBA Chair, said:
“With minimum densities, housing mix policies, and other obligations like BNG, highways, SUDs etc, hectares, or other area measurements, are not a good metric to determine site size category.
For SMEs, the commercial viability of a development is calculated using plot numbers, so to use other thresholds and measurements would be a misunderstanding of how things work at this scale and counterproductive to the real-world activation of the SME housebuilding sector.”
In ‘Size ‘still’ Matters: Dwellings Matter more’ we build on our ‘Size Matters’ report 2025 – which introduced four site size thresholds alongside our seven-year campaign for a ‘Medium’ sized site – to explain why our proposals did not include measured area thresholds and why the Government’s future consultation on a ‘Medium’ sized site should follow that lead.
Focusing exclusively on ‘Medium’ sized sites, ‘Size Still Matters’ explores:
  • LPA responses to the NPPF consultation which introduced the 1-hectare limit
  • Whether that subsequent NPPF policy to support SMEs and smaller sites succeeded
  • How Local Plans, supported by national policy, already shape locally appropriate dwelling per hectare (dph) levels.
  • Explores how housing developments are giving over more land for non-residential needs, and why that land take is increasing.
  • What type of projects are most likely to benefit from the proposal as currently conceived.
  • Why most SMEs will not benefit from an area-based measurement.
Rico Wojtulewicz, Head of Policy and Market insight for the NFB and House Builders Association (HBA), said:
“We are incredibly grateful that the Government has listened to industry by recognising the dwelling numbers that SMEs typically deliver on single sites. However, the inclusion of a measured area threshold risks excluding most SMEs from the proportionate planning reforms associated with a Medium sized site, and so our report ‘Size Still Matters’ illustrates why that is and why it is not needed.”

EAN Breaking News

Breaking News from the team at Estate Agent Networking. Have a new story to share with us? Then please get in contact today! When and where we can we will refer to third party websites with a 'live link back' where news was released first.

You May Also Enjoy

Rightmove logo
Breaking News

Rightmove asks government to carefully consider property tax changes

The UK’s largest property platform Rightmove is asking the government to carefully consider the impact of any changes to property taxation to avoid unintended consequences which would risk stalling parts of the market. Key data National property tax Just under a third (30%) of homes for sale in England are priced at over £500,000, and…
Read More
Estate Agent Talk

Get Fast and Reliable Basement Flood Cleaning Services

Having water in your basement is awful. It could be because of a storm, busted pipe, or bad sump pump. Whatever the reason, water damage in your basement has disastrous effects if not dealt with. Basement Flood Cleaning Services are what you need. They will dry it out, disinfect the floor, and have your basement…
Read More
Breaking News

Breaking Property News 21/08/25

Daily bite-sized proptech and property news in partnership with Proptech-X.   Providing comprehensive, predictive operational intelligence across all aspects of building operations  JLL (NYSE: JLL) this week introduced artificial intelligence (AI) capabilities that are now available as an add-on to Prism, its award-winning building operations platform. As part of JLL’s property management technology ecosystem powered by…
Read More
Breaking News

UK House Price Index summary: June 2025

The average monthly rate of house price growth in June was 1.4%. The average annual rate of house price growth in June was 3.7%, up from 2.7% in May. As a result, the average UK house price remains at £269,000.   CEO of Yopa, Verona Frankish, commented: “June’s figures reflect a market that is steadily…
Read More
Breaking News

Private rent and house prices, UK: August 2025

Average UK monthly private rents increased by 5.9%, to £1,343, in the 12 months to July 2025 (provisional estimate); this annual growth rate is down from 6.7% in the 12 months to June 2025. Average rents increased to £1,398 (6.0%) in England, £807 (7.9%) in Wales, and £999 (3.6%) in Scotland, in the 12 months…
Read More
Breaking News

Industry response to latest inflation figures

Nathan Emerson, CEO of Propertymark, comments: “Unfortunately, any increase seen within the rate of inflation does brings very justified concerns to consumers, many of whom are still struggling with the cost of living, which has been steadily rising over the past few years. “Although there is more work to be done to help ensure inflation…
Read More