Why your canvassing isn’t working and how to FIX it

When you design your canvassing campaign, here’s the five step journey you probably hope most vendors will take:

Step 1 – Receive canvassing leaflet

Step 2 – Call office to book MA

Step 3 – Have MA

Step 4 – Sign sale agreement

Step 5 – Sell property

There’s a problem with this journey however; homeowners do NOT proceed from step 1 to step 2; well, not often enough.  And if you can’t get them to step 2, the whole journey is broken.

Looking at metrics like retention, conversion and response rates, you’d need to send out 11,100 canvassing pieces to get just ONE instruction through to a successful sale.

Here’s how the figures stack up:

Step Action % #
1 Send out leaflets 11,100
2 Phone responses 0.02% 222
3 Valuation 95% 2.11
4 Instruction 50% 1.05
5 Sale 95% 1

So if canvassing isn’t working effectively, what can we do to improve it?

I’m going to suggest a completely different strategy is now needed.

Have you heard the term ‘permission marketing’?

Here’s the official definition:

“Permission marketing is the privilege (not the right) of delivering anticipated, personal and relevant messages to people who actually want to get them. It recognises the new power of the best consumers to ignore marketing. It realises that treating people with respect is the best way to earn their attention.”

Interruption marketing is the opposite of permission marketing.  Interruption marketing interrupts our tv watching, our magazine reading, our email checking, and more.  Now contrast that to my Supertips emails. Those agents who get my Supertips will tell you the information contained in these emails is useful, timely and innovative, full of creative tips and unusual tactics to help you get through more doors and win more instructions.

My Supertips emails don’t say: “I’m fantastic”, or “Buy my stuff!” If they did, you would be reaching for the unsubscribe button straight away.

What I’m doing by being useful in the emails I send out, and not trying to sell you anything, is building a relationship based on trust, over time, in a consistent manner.

By sending you information and asking for nothing in return, I earn the right to talk to you about your business down the line if and when you are ready for it.

So what are you doing to build your relationships with your future clients, over time, in a systematic way? How are you earning the right to talk to them about their potential property sale, down the line?

It’s time to make permission marketing the basis to your canvassing.

This strategy will help you build a solid foundation to form and nurture a successful relationship with your future clients; a relationship you can then rely on when these vendors decide to sell, to ensure you are top of mind, and their favourite agent, even before you step through the door.

Let’s talk about subscribers

Subscribers are those people who join your email list or database via an action they have taken themselves. It could be that they exchange their email address for your ebook or that they have entered a contest you’ve run. Whatever the method, so long as they have taken the action and been rewarded with the response they wanted, they should be happy to hear from you.

Let’s run the same journey as before, but to generate subscribers, instead of  direct to market appraisals:

Step Action % #
1 Send out leaflets 11,100
NEW Subscribers 1% 111
NEW Email response 50% 56
2 Phone conversation 70% 39
3 Valuation 30% 12
4 Instruction 70% 8
5 Sale 95% 8

You’ll see then that even at only a 1% subscriber rate, you could end up with eight completed sales.  Of course, your subscriber rate could be lower, or even higher. But whatever your response rate is, I promise you that it will be significantly higher than your response rate would be if you were just going straight for the valuation.

Working the numbers back, I calculate that at average fee of £2500, the same 111 subscribers could be worth £174.56 each, meaning that your new list of potential vendors could be worth a total of £19,376.44.  At an estimated cost of £1000 to have your canvassing leaflet designed, printed and delivered to 11,000 households, that’s a return on investment of 1900% – that’s a pretty decent return, I think.

I appreciate that this is a new, radical way of using canvassing to generate new business. Using a permission-first, nurture-focused strategy definitely requires a shift in mindset and when you’re used to traditional marketing methods, that’s not an easy shift to make.  But estate agency is changing, and so must you.

So change now, before you have to.

What to do next: Sign up to my Supertips to discover how I use permission marketing to attract you and nurture the relationship over time.  Get yours here -> www.samashdown.co.uk/supertips

What to read next: Not Your Father’s Marketing

Speak to Sam: If you’d like to know how I think you could improve your marketing, just answer a few short questions here and I’ll tell you if and how you could be more effective.

Sam Ashdown

Sam is an industry-renowned marketing strategist to estate agents. She helps agents grow and flourish, using her unique smart marketing techniques and strategies. Sam works with agents throughout the UK to help them gain more valuations, win more instructions and sell more properties.

You May Also Enjoy

Breaking News

More tenants enter the rental market

Tenant demand climbs across England in Q1 as rental market pressure builds for letting agents The latest research by The Letting Partnership has found that tenant demand across England remained strong during the first quarter of 2026, with 27.4% of all rental listings already securing a tenant, meaning that the country’s hottest rental markets are…
Read More
Estate Agent Talk

7 Ways Estate Agents Can Adapt to a Changing Property Market

The UK property landscape is evolving rapidly, and estate agents are under increasing pressure to implement innovative strategies. With shifting buyer expectations, new technologies, and alternative sales models entering the market, adapting your approach is essential. So, if you’re looking to see success with your agency, here are just seven key ways you can remain…
Read More
Letting Agent Talk

Spring clean drives high maintenance bill for landlord

The latest market insight from property management specialist, Rushbrook & Rathbone, suggests that property maintenance spend is set to surge in April, as the annual ‘spring clean’ by landlords saw the month account for the second highest proportion of total annual maintenance spend in 2025, as well as the largest average spend per work order. Rushbrook…
Read More
Breaking News

65% of homebuyers blame slow process on conveyancers

The latest research from Lyons Bowe reveals that 65% of recent homebuyers say the conveyancing process was the slowest part of their buying process, with a quarter saying the legal back and forth took more than 16 weeks to complete. Lyons Bowe commissioned a survey of 1,000 UK homeowners who made a purchase in the past…
Read More
Breaking News

UK Construction Activity Collapses

Glenigan’s April Construction Index uncovers an industry struggling to cushion the blows from ongoing international conflict and a persistently weak economy. Work starting on-site declined by 17% compared to Q4, remaining 18% below 2025 levels. Residential construction starts dropped by 13% during the Index period and fell by 30% against 2025 figures. Non-residential project-starts dipped…
Read More
Breaking News

Homebuyer demand down in Q1 2026

Buyer demand slips in Q1 2026, with South of England outperformed by North and Midlands The latest Sales Demand Index from eXp UK has revealed that homebuyer demand in England slipped by -1.6% in Q1 2026. The analysis also reveals a clear north-south divide with counties located in the midlands or north of the country recording…
Read More