Government vs Property – does Nanny know best?

Whether it’s to do with our sugar intake, types of cars we drive or consumption of fruit each day, it seems the Government have our best interests at heart. So one would assume that when the powers that be, “fine-tune” the property market, that they are looking to help us all. Their thinking is that by aiming to put off wealthier property investors through higher tax rates, they will open up the market to help first time buyers get on to the property ladder. This surely can only be a good thing, after all nanny knows best – or does she?

The current government intervention revolves around several points, the most significant of which is the 3% stamp duty surcharge for second home and additional property purchases. This has been widely seen as a tax on the wealthy who can afford it and effectively passing the savings down the line. Sounds fair, doesn’t it?

The Government have taken a new approach with the surcharge, having closed off many loopholes from the start. Married couples are classed as one entity, so putting additional properties in each other’s name would not work. Conversely, divorcing couples could still pay the surcharge, unless the main family residence was sold within 36 months. Even then, the charge would still have to be paid upfront and reclaimed down the line.

In addition, there are to be introduced tougher lending criteria and stress testing on hypothetical interest rates of up to 5.5%, plus investigation of one’s wider finances. Many would argue this already exists, but again is aimed by the Government to throw would-be property investors off the scent.

In the recent Budget Statement, George Osborne introduced rules that from next year, landlords being able to offset all their mortgage interest against their final year tax bill, will be phased out. Therefore, by the end of the decade, higher rate tax payers will be half the relief they do now. If that wasn’t enough, Capital Gains Tax (which is the tax payable on realised gains) was reduced in the Budget. However, the sale of residential property was excluded from this. Therefore, there is effectively an 8% tax increase on any uplift if you sell.

So what is the Government’s problem and why do they feel the need to get involved?

The Government feels that property investors have a competitive advantage and are vying for the same types of properties as first time buyers. Their aim is to lend a hand to those trying to get on the first steps of the property ladder. By creating what they feel to be market stability, should the economy ever get tough again, then the UK was insulated from the storm, plus the banks were covered… again!

By increasing the upfront costs to property investors, the Government hopes to ease demand, creating a greater supply of first time buyer properties. What a great idea you may say! In actual fact, Nanny has been caught unaware!

By effectively putting the brakes on buy-to-let investors, the Government has choked up the supply of rental properties for would-be first time buyers. As a result, demand has increased and therefore monthly rentals have done so too. Therefore, if you are a tenant, how are you now meant to save for your first home?

Don’t worry Nanny says, here is an increase on your annual ISA allowance, plus an all new “Lifetime ISA”. But hold on, if I’m a tenant paying more rent, how am I still able to find extra money each month to save in my new ISA!

The issue remains that first time buyers will still find is difficult to save for their deposit. Plus, now with the Government’s tougher lending criteria, everyone could potentially lose out. Nanny better have her wits about her over the ensuing months and keep a close check. If you thought Nanny knew best when it came to property, you may wish to think again!

Alex Evans

You May Also Enjoy

Breaking News

Newcastle and Edinburgh commuter belts beat London

The latest research from The Property DriveBuy has found that Newcastle and Edinburgh rank as the best commuter belts in Britain, with all surrounding local authorities offering a more affordable average house price than the cities themselves, whilst Liverpool ranks as the worst. The Property DriveBuy analysed current house prices across 12 major British cities,…
Read More
Breaking News

Breaking Property News 16/10/25

Daily bite-sized proptech and property news in partnership with Proptech-X. Tlyfe and Eleos Life partnership brings embedded insurance protection to UK Renters In a first for the UK rental sector, Tlyfe (powered by OpenBrix) has partnered with digital insurer Eleos Life by adding embed life and income protection directly into its tenant app. Instead of…
Read More
Breaking News

Sellers of larger homes make £122.5k average capital gains, crushing the gains from flats

Sellers of detached homes made £122,500 in capital gains when selling their home over the last 18 months while flats yielded an average gain of £27,000 Sellers in England and Wales made an average gain of £72,000, a 38 per cent increase in value from when they bought the property The average seller in London…
Read More
Breaking News

London’s second homeowners face £16,446 CGT bill

London’s second homeowners face £16,446 capital gains tax bill, but prime London sellers escaping unscathed The latest research from Enness Global has found that whilst the London property market remains subdued, the city’s second homeowners could still be hit with significant costs when exiting their investments, with the average seller now facing a capital gains…
Read More
Love or Hate Rightmove
Estate Agent Talk

Rightmove launches new webinar to equip agents with market leading insights and business-boosting strategies

Rightmove, the UK’s largest property platform, is launching a new webinar to equip agents with the latest market intelligence and profit-boosting strategies to accelerate sales and improve conversion rates. The webinar titled, ‘From pitch to profit: Competing on more than just fee’, will take place live on Friday 17th October at 1pm, exclusively for Rightmove…
Read More
Estate Agent Talk

60% of homeowners admit to stress & sleepless nights

Managing your mortgage and mental health as 60% of homeowners admit to stress and sleepless nights The latest insight from award-winning mortgage adviser, Alexander Hall, has shown that for the majority of homeowners, their mortgage is their single largest financial worry, with 60% stating that their mortgage worries have impacted their mental health at one…
Read More