Are rogue landlords sitting on £1.2 billion in unaccounted tenancy deposits?

The latest research by Hamilton Fraser’s deposit replacement provider, Ome, has revealed the huge sums of tenant money that is estimated as being held by landlords and agents without protection via a deposit protection scheme.

Ome’s sister company, mydeposits, manages 25% of the total deposit protection market and their latest records show they currently protect more than 876,000 live deposits, suggesting there is an estimated 3.5m deposits protected across the entire market which equates to some £3.9bn in value!

This means that with 3.5m protected tenancy to a value of £3.9bn, the average tenant is paying £1,139 for a tenancy deposit.

Ome compared these statistics with the latest English Housing Survey report which shows an estimated 4.60m tenancies in the private rental sector in 2019. With only 3.5m of these tenancy deposits accounted for in protection schemes, there are potentially 1.1m tenancies that either have not had a deposit protected, do not have deposits, or are using deposit replacement products. At worst, there could be as much as £1.2bn in deposit monies that are not protected.

However, the latest report into deposit protection compliance rates by the Center for Economics and Business Research (CEBR) estimates that 14.5% of all deposits held are not protected by landlords or agents. This means of the estimated 1.1m tenancy deposits that are unaccounted for, just over 500,000 (14.5%) cash deposits could currently be unprotected, putting £578m at risk.

However, this would suggest there are still some 586,000 tenancies in the private rental sector that are neither compliant nor unprotected, suggesting a growing preference amongst landlords to ditch the traditional cash deposit.

Landlord’s deposit taking habits are changing

This could be explained by two factors: firstly the increased acceptance of deposit replacement products such as Ome and, secondly, some landlords opting to request no deposit at all, with the latest research showing as many as 600,000 tenancies in the private rental sector currently opting for one of these two options.

The lack of a rental deposit is already a theme becoming popular with “Build-to-Rent” providers who operate large numbers of rental units and forgo a traditional deposit, mitigating the risk by providing additional complimentary services such as cleaning to their tenants.

As the industry becomes more service-orientated and changes to legislation lead to tenants receiving more consumer protection, landlords and agents are looking at ways in which they can streamline their businesses, with innovation in the deposit sector looking to be fertile ground.

But for those 500,000 landlords across the nation that have taken a deposit and failed to place it in a compliant protection scheme, there are consequences. They run the risk of fines of up to three times the deposit plus the deposit itself. At £1,139 for the average new deposit, it could cost them to the tune of £4,556 per unprotected deposit!

Co-founder of Ome, Matthew Hooker, commented:

“The reality is that the private rental sector is changing, and has been changing gradually through the formal introduction of deposit protection in 2006 and the subsequent launch of the more traditional protection schemes.

It’s impossible to tell just how many deposits are still sat unprotected in the bank accounts of either rogue landlords or agents but based on market data we can make a conservative estimate that this total value runs into the hundreds of millions of pounds.

We’d always advise tenants to check which deposit protection scheme your agent or landlord is part of and to make sure they give you the documentation confirming the deposit is protected.

For landlords and agents that would rather not have to worry about the often arduous and risky process of managing a deposit, we’d recommend looking at products such as our own deposit replacement membership rather than hoping they don’t get caught. It removes the need to take cash deposits but keeps you protected should the worst happen.”

Data on Protected Tenancy Deposits
Live Deposits Protected
Total Value
Average Deposit Paid
876,249
£998,048,056
£1,139
3,504,996
£3,992,192,224
£1,139.00
Hamilton Fraser’s Data
Hamilton Fraser’s data (25% market share) multiplied by 4.
Total Value Divided by Number of Deposits
Data on Total and Unaccounted for Deposits
Total Tenancies
Number of Deposits Accounted For
Number of Unaccounted Tenancies
Value of Unaccounted Tenancies
4,600,000
3,504,996
1,095,004
£1,247,209,556
Based on Total Deposits Protected in the Above Table
Based on Total Tenancies Minus Number Accounted For
Number Unaccounted Tenancies Multiplied by Average Deposit Above
Data on Potentially Unprotected and Unaccounted for Deposits
% of Non-Compliant Tenancies (Unprotected)
Number of Unprotected Deposits
Value of Unprotected Tenancies
Deposits Completely Unaccounted For
14.50%
508224
£578,867,614
586,780
14.5% of Total Deposits Unaccounted for in Above Table
Number of Unprotected Tenancies Multiplied by Average Deposit Paid
The Difference Between Total Unaccounted Tenancies and Total Unprotected Tenancies

Properganda PR

National and local media coverage for property businesses. Journo quotes delivered in minutes.

You May Also Enjoy

small house bird box
Breaking News

UK First Time Buyers better off than many other global nations

Is it really that bad being a first-time buyer? UK better off than many other global nations when it comes to affordability The latest market analysis from Yopa, the full-service estate agents, reveals that first-time buyers (FTBs) in the UK may be paying 63% more to get a foot on the property ladder than they…
Read More
new build homes colchester essex
Breaking News

Building Safety Regulator Reform

The Government has announced reforms to the Building Safety Regulator, including leadership, process and investment. The changes are hoped to deliver 1.5 million homes. The reforms pave the way for creation of a single construction safety regulator, as recommended by the Grenfell Tower enquiry. David Smith, property litigation partner at London law firm Spector Constant…
Read More
Breaking News

New anti-money laundering rules now in effect: what landlords need to know

New anti-money laundering (AML) rules came into effect this month, marking a significant change for landlords and the lettings industry as a whole. The new rules mean financial sanctions checks are now required for all lettings, regardless of how much rent is charged. Here, Steve Bond, managing director of residential lettings for Beresfords, explains what…
Read More
Breaking News

What landlords need to know about the upcoming Renters Rights Bill

The government’s long-awaited Renters Rights Bill is one of the most significant overhauls of the private rental sector in decades. While it has not yet received royal assent, the legislation is expected to come into effect late this year, or early in 2026. With the bill moving closer to becoming law, Steven Bond, managing director…
Read More
Breaking News

Mortgage approvals bounce back in May

The latest figures show that: – Mortgage approvals on house purchases for May sat at 63,032 up 3.9% from 60,656 in April. The monthly increase seen in May marks the end of four months of previous decline, with approval levels having fallen each month since January of this year. Approvals are also 2.5% higher than…
Read More
Breaking News

Money and Credit – May 2025

Key points: Net borrowing of mortgage debt by individuals increased by £2.8 billion to £2.1 billion in May, following a large decrease in net borrowing of £13.8 billion to -£0.8 billion in April. Net mortgage approvals for house purchases increased by 2,400 to 63,000 in May. Approvals for remortgaging also increased by 6,200 to 41,500…
Read More