Classic cars, coins and fine wine have been the best investments in the last five years

Just a day after posting its biggest one day decline, the price of gold skyrocketed last week as scares over the spread of the coronavirus caused a ‘flight into safe havens’ by many investors.

However, the latest research by peer to peer lending platform, Sourced Capital, has found that over the last five years, gold has been one of the worst investments one can make.

Sourced Capital looked at the average annual rate of return across a number of traditional investment options over the last five years, which are topping the table as the most lucrative and what return you would have gained from a £1,000 investment.

The research shows that classic cars have been the best investment in the last five years, with an average annual rate of return hitting 16% meaning a £1,000 investment would see a return of £1,136 today in addition to your original investment.

While gold hasn’t fared so well, investing in rare coins has been a pretty safe bet, returning an additional £1,033 on a £1,000 investment with the average annual rate of return sitting at 15%.

Fine wines rank as the third most lucrative investment returning an average of 13% each year or £859 on your investment.

While prime bricks and mortar hasn’t performed well with an average annual RoR of just 6%, investing through a peer to peer lending platform such as Souced has proved a much better option, with an annual RoR of 10% returning £611 in addition to a £1,000 investment.

Vintage watches (8%) jewellery (7%) and good old fashioned stamps (7%) have proved the next safest bet, while the FTSE 100 (6%) sits on par with prime property investment and as previously mentioned, gold brings up the rear with an average annual RoR of just 5% over the last five years.

Stephen Moss, founder and MD of Sourced Capital, commented: 

“The recent surge in the popularity of gold is likely to be short lived and although it can bring some huge returns, these more volatile options are also prone to huge losses.

When it comes to the more stable investment options, the classics such as cars, rare coins and fine wine seem to bring the most consistent returns on a long term basis. That said, while bricks and mortar has traditionally been as safe as houses, a Brexit inspired market slowdown has even seen that drop down the table.

However, we’ve also seen investment in the property sector evolve as a result with a greater preference to invest via peer to peer platforms and while capital is always at risk, new age options such as the Innovative Finance ISA have seen many investors average 10% annually through property investment, with some achieving returns as high as 12%.

Of course, for the professional investor spreading your investments across a number of options not only diversifies your portfolio but mitigates the risk from the more volatile investment classes while allowing you to make the most of the various rates of return available.”

What is an IFISA?

The IFISA is a category of ISA which was launched in April 2016 for UK taxpayers and can provide returns as high as 10-12% an annum, although capital is of, course, at risk. Previously, there have been two main types of ISA: Cash ISAs and Stocks and Shares ISAs.

Similar to these ISAs, the IFISA allows you to invest money without paying personal income tax. This enables you to invest your money into the growing peer to peer market.

Like cash ISAs Each tax year, you get an allowance of up to £20,000 to put into IFISAs which you can distribute across your different ISAs should you wish to. In addition, you can transfer your previous year’s ISA investments into your IFISA.

Average annual rate of return (2015-now)
Type
Average %
Classic Cars
16%
Coins
15%
Fine Wine
13%
Sourced – property development
10%
Vintage Watches
8%
Jewellery
7%
Stamps
7%
Prime property investment
6%
FTSE 100
6%
Gold
5%
Return on £1,000 invested
Type
£ gained (from 2015-2019)
Classic Cars
£1,136
Coins
£1,033
Fine Wine
£859
Sourced – property development
£611
Vintage Watches
£496
Jewellery
£386
Stamps
£380
Prime property investment
£343
FTSE 100
£326
Gold
£264
£1000 investment in the last five years
Year
Classic Cars
Classic cars investment – ave rate %
Classic cars investment £
start
–
£1,000
2015
16.39%
£1,164
2016
16.39%
£1,355
2017
16.39%
£1,577
2018
16.39%
£1,835
2019
16.39%
£2,136
Year
Coins
Coins investment – ave rate %
Coins investment £
start
–
£1,000
2015
15.25%
£1,153
2016
15.25%
£1,328
2017
15.25%
£1,531
2018
15.25%
£1,764
2019
15.25%
£2,033
Year
Fine Wine
Fine wine investment – ave rate %
Fine wine investment £
start
–
£1,000
2015
13.20%
£1,132
2016
13.20%
£1,281
2017
13.20%
£1,451
2018
13.20%
£1,642
2019
13.20%
£1,859
Year
Sourced property development
Sourced property development – ave rate %
Property development – Sourced £
start
–
£1,000
2015
10%
£1,100
2016
10%
£1,210
2017
10%
£1,331
2018
10%
£1,464
2019
10%
£1,611
Year
Vintage Watches
Vintage watches investment – ave rate %
Vintage watches investment £
start
–
£1,000
2015
8.39%
£1,084
2016
8.39%
£1,175
2017
8.39%
£1,273
2018
8.39%
£1,380
2019
8.39%
£1,496
Year
Jewellery
Jewellery investment – ave rate %
Jewellery investment £
start
–
£1,000
2015
6.74%
£1,067
2016
6.74%
£1,139
2017
6.74%
£1,216
2018
6.74%
£1,298
2019
6.74%
£1,386
Year
Stamps
Stamps investment – ave rate %
Stamps investment £
start
–
£1,000
2015
6.65%
£1,067
2016
6.65%
£1,137
2017
6.65%
£1,213
2018
6.65%
£1,294
2019
6.65%
£1,380
Year
Property – Prime
Property investment ave rate %
Property investment £
start
–
£1,000
2015
6.07%
£1,061
2016
6.07%
£1,125
2017
6.07%
£1,193
2018
6.07%
£1,266
2019
6.07%
£1,343
Year
FTSE 100
FTSE 100 – ave rate %
FTSE 100 – investment £
start
–
£1,000
2015
5.80%
£1,058
2016
5.80%
£1,119
2017
5.80%
£1,184
2018
5.80%
£1,253
2019
5.80%
£1,326
Year
Gold
Gold – ave rate %
Gold – investment £
start
–
£1,000
2015
4.80%
£1,048
2016
4.80%
£1,098
2017
4.80%
£1,151
2018
4.80%
£1,206
2019
4.80%
£1,264

 

Sources for the average annual rate of return
Peer to peer lending
Sourced Capital data
FTSE 100 info
Gold prices
Others

Properganda PR

National and local media coverage for property businesses. Journo quotes delivered in minutes.

You May Also Enjoy

Breaking News

London rents outperform property values

The latest research by London lettings and estate agent, Benham and Reeves, has revealed that rental growth has outperformed house price growth across 26 of London’s 32 boroughs since the start of the year, with rents continuing to climb despite weaker property price performance across much of the capital. Benham and Reeves analysed the average…
Read More →
Breaking News

Rental property availability falls

The number of rental properties available across England fell by 12.1% during the third quarter of 2026, according to new analysis by Dwelly, highlighting an increasingly competitive rental market in many parts of the country. Dwelly is one of the UK’s largest rental property management groups, with more than 15,000 properties under management. The firm’s…
Read More →
Breaking News

Average advertised rents surpass £1,400 for the first time

The average advertised rent of homes outside London has risen to a new record of £1,418 per calendar month, up 1.5% this quarter: Despite a new record rent, annual rental growth has returned to a more stable level of +2.4% Number of available rental homes nationally is 2% lower than a year ago, while renter…
Read More →
Breaking News

Barclays unlocks wider mortgage access for company directors

Limited company directors who meet the income threshold can now have their Profit After Tax (PAT) considered in their affordability assessment regardless of property value The change means that, for a wider group of limited company directors, Barclays will consider a fuller view of the applicant’s income The update is the latest in a series…
Read More →
Breaking News

Homebuyer demand fall in Q3

The latest sales demand data from eXp UK has revealed that homebuyer demand in England slipped by -1.6% in Q3 2026. The analysis shows that just five counties managed positive growth during the quarter, suggesting that buyers may be holding back, adopting a wait-and-see approach ahead of what promises to be a vital Autumn Budget –…
Read More →
Estate Agent Talk

Alterations can change a property’s rebuild cost

‘Don’t get caught short’ warning to homeowners from valuations experts – alterations can change a property’s rebuild cost Properties change over time. Homeowners may add an extension, upgrade a kitchen or bathroom, alter the layout, or even change how the building is used, but when do those changes mean it’s time for a new rebuild…
Read More →