Crime pays for buy-to-let landlords but here are the safest yield hotspots for B2L peace of mind

Research by the national lettings platform, Howsy, has looked at how crime rates impact rental yields and where offers the best buy-to-let investment with the highest return and the lowest propensity for crime.

Howsy looked at government data on population figures by local authority, the level of crime in these areas, the average house price, rental costs, and the resulting rental yields to see how crime and buy-to-let profitability correlates.

With greater demand and higher rental prices often found in larger urban hubs, the data shows that the average rental yield actually increases as the level of crime does.

In the lowest threshold between 0 and 40 crimes per thousand people where there is an average of 34 crimes per thousand of the population, the average rental yield sits at 3.58%.

Between the threshold of 60-80 crimes per thousand people, this increases to 3.77% and in the highest category of 100 or more crimes per thousand people with an average of 123 crimes committed per thousand people, rental yields are at their highest – 4.38%.

But a higher likelihood of crime can cause landlords headaches, whether it be through burglary and damage to their property from an external source or the unlucky instance that their tenant is a criminal and causes this damage themselves or fails to pay the rent. The worst-case scenario is a buy-to-let property doubling as a drug den, grow house or brothel and this can have a serious impact on the financial income of a landlord.

So for those looking to invest with greater peace of mind without sacrificing a return on their investment, here are the best places to do it.

In the lowest crime category of 0-40, Merthyr Tydfil is home to the highest yields. With an average house price of £102,713 and an average monthly rent of £472, landlords can expect yields of 5.52% with the lowest chance of crime impacting their investment.

Staying in Wales, Rhondda Cynon Taff is the second safest investment with yields of 4.50%. North East Derbyshire ranks third (3.84%), followed by North Kesteven (3.75%), West Oxfordshire (3.67%), Wealden (3.64%), East Cambridgeshire (3.60%), Rutland (3.52%), Broadland (3.32%) and South Norfolk (3.30%).

Founder and CEO of Howsy, Calum Brannan, commented:

“Financial gain is understandably the driving factor in any buy-to-let investment but money isn’t everything and there have been numerous horror stories of rental properties being misused and mistreated for criminal gain or just flat out burgled causing a great deal of damage in the process.

This is a nightmare scenario for a buy-to-let landlord and as many don’t live close to their property, it means a lot of time and money spent to rectify the situation. This all eats into the profitability of your investment and can even result in a landlord selling up and exiting the sector altogether.

So when looking to invest, it’s smart to consider the additional factors that can impact your property and not just the top line return.”

Categories – crime rate vs average rental yield
Crime rate category (per thousand)
Average crime rate (per thousand)
Average Rental Yield %
0-40
34.02
3.58%
40-60
52.05
3.55%
60-80
68.91
3.77%
80-100
89.20
4.20%
100+
123.20
4.38%
All categories
76.39
3.91%

 

Ranking – by highest average rental yield in the lowest crime category
Location
Average Rental Yield %
Merthyr Tydfil
5.52%
Rhondda Cynon Taf
4.50%
North East Derbyshire
3.84%
North Kesteven
3.75%
West Oxfordshire
3.67%
Wealden
3.64%
East Cambridgeshire
3.60%
Rutland
3.52%
Broadland
3.32%
South Norfolk
3.30%

 

Sources:
Population (Local Authority)
ONS
Crime data
Ave House Price
Gov / LandReg
Ave Private Rent
Gov – Eng
Gov – Wales

 

Properganda PR

National and local media coverage for property businesses. Journo quotes delivered in minutes.

You May Also Enjoy

Breaking News

Christmas rental voids jumps by almost 40%

Cost of Christmas rental voids jumps by almost 40% as landlords face £1,350 income shortfall   The cost of an empty rental property has risen by 38.6% in the last year, with landlords in England now facing an estimated £1,350 in lost rental income during a typical void period, up £376 compared with last Christmas…
Read More →
Breaking News

UK property transactions forecast to fall 4.4% in 2026

The latest property market forecast from eXp UK suggests that residential transactions across the UK are on course to fall by 4.4% in 2026, with market activity expected to finish below last year’s levels before rebounding by 6.7% in 2027. eXp UK analysed quarterly property transaction trends across England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland dating…
Read More →
Breaking News

London renters paying £1,000 more a year in rent

The latest research by London lettings and estate agent, Benham and Reeves, has revealed that the average annual cost of renting in London has climbed by almost £1,000 over the last year, with 11 boroughs seeing increases of more than £1,000 and two recording hikes in excess of £2,000. Benham and Reeves analysed the latest…
Read More →
Breaking News

UK Inflation Hits 3.6%: What Rising Prices Mean for House Prices

UK inflation rose to 3.6% in October, sparking cautious concern across the property and mortgage sectors. With price pressures holding firm, industry leaders warn that further Bank of England base rate hikes remain on the table, dashing hopes of any immediate relief on high fixed-rate mortgage deals for buyers and landlords.   Nathan Emerson, CEO…
Read More →
Breaking News

Average UK Property Value Hits £273,000 Despite Monthly Dip in September

UK House Price Index Summary for September 2026 The average monthly rate of house price growth in September declined slightly to -0.5%. The average annual rate of house price growth in September was up +1.2%. As a result, the average UK house price is now £273,000.   Thoughts from the Industry:   Director of Benham and…
Read More →
Breaking News

UK Rents Hit £1,411 as House Prices Edge Up 1.2%

Average UK monthly private rent increased by 3.8%, to £1,411, in the 12 months to October 2026 (provisional estimate); this annual growth rate is unchanged from the 12 months to September 2026. Average rents increased to £1,472 (4.0%) in England, £849 (3.9%) in Wales, and £1,015 (0.7%) in Scotland, in the 12 months to October…
Read More →