Death of the Cash ISA – Big banks are struggling to cope with the mass Cash ISAodus

The latest market insight and research from peer to peer lending platform, Sourced Capital of the Sourced.co Group, has revealed that a mass exodus of Cash ISA investors submitting transfer out requests from their Cash ISAs is causing a backlog with the big bank lenders.

Sourced Capital was recently advised by HSBC that transfers were taking a while to process and were requesting no calls for updates due to the substantial backlog, yet further indication of the death of the Cash ISA as investors look for more lucrative options.

This is a trend that has been apparent for some time due to record low-interest rates and one that will no doubt be exacerbated with the Bank of England’s decision to keep rates frozen yet again at 0.75%.

In fact, since 2008 the number of accounts subscribed to a Cash ISA has declined every year except one, with the total number down -36.38% all in all, averaging an annual decline of -4.69%.

Some of the biggest annual declines have come over the last year and the year prior to that, with the number of Cash ISA accounts dropping by a notable -8.22% and -16.19% respectively.

Prior to the economic crisis, available rates averaged at 5%, but in more recent times this return has diminished to around 1.45%.

It’s clear that the preference of investing in a Cash ISA is well and truly on the slide and those looking to make their money work harder are opting for alternative investment options like the Innovative Finance ISA.

The IFISA is a category of ISA which was launched in April 2016 for UK taxpayers. Previously, there have been two main types of ISA: Cash ISAs and Stocks and Shares ISAs. Similar to these ISAs, the IFISA allows you to invest money without paying personal income tax. This enables you to invest your money into the growing peer to peer market.

Like cash ISAs Each tax year, you get an allowance of up to £20,000 to put into IFISAs which you can distribute across your different ISAs should you wish to. In addition, you can transfer your previous year’s ISA investments into your IFISA and while your capital is of course, at risk, an IFISA can bring returns of as much as 10-12%.

Founder and Managing Director of Sourced Capital, Stephen Moss, commented:

“A prolonged period of extremely low-interest rates has been great for some and has helped stimulate borrowing and spending activity, most notably across the UK property and mortgage sectors. However, it hasn’t been great for those attempting to accumulate a sizable savings pot with the return on their hard-earned cash remaining really rather poor.

It comes as no surprise then that the declining health of the Cash ISA seen in recent years has now progressed to an almost fatal level as more and more investors remove their cash and look elsewhere for a more favourable return. This exodus has been spurred by more innovative options providing a better return and has become so prevalent that even the biggest lenders are struggling to cope with the paperwork.”

CASH ISA – Number of accounts subscribed in current year (thousands)
Period
Number of accounts subscribed in current year (thousands)
Change / growth (yearly)
2008-09
12,234
x
2009-10
11,426
-6.60%
2010-11
11,859
3.79%
2011-12
11,187
-5.67%
2012-13
11,682
4.42%
2013-14
10,481
-10.28%
2014-15
10,288
-1.84%
2015-16
10,118
-1.65%
2016-17
8,480
-16.19%
2017-18
7,783
-8.22%
Total Growth
-36.38%
Average Annual Growth
-4.69%
CASH ISA – Amounts subscribed (£millions)
Period
Amounts subscribed (£millions)
Change / growth (yearly)
2008-09
£30,383
x
2009-10
£31,437
3.47%
2010-11
£38,197
21.50%
2011-12
£37,222
-2.55%
2012-13
£40,901
9.88%
2013-14
£38,821
-5.09%
2014-15
£60,951
57.01%
2015-16
£58,694
-3.70%
2016-17
£39,191
-33.23%
2017-18
£39,801
1.56%
Total Growth
31.00%
Average Annual Growth
5.43%
CASH ISA – Average subscription per account (£)
Period
Average subscription per account (£)
Change / growth (yearly)
2008-09
£2,483
x
2009-10
£2,751
10.79%
2010-11
£3,221
17.08%
2011-12
£3,327
3.29%
2012-13
£3,501
5.23%
2013-14
£3,704
5.80%
2014-15
£5,924
59.94%
2015-16
£5,801
-2.08%
2016-17
£4,622
-20.32%
2017-18
£5,114
10.64%
Total Growth
105.96%
Average Annual Growth
10.04%

Properganda PR

National and local media coverage for property businesses. Journo quotes delivered in minutes.

You May Also Enjoy

Rightmove logo
Breaking News

Rightmove’s Weekly Mortgage Tracker – 01/07/25

Average rates for 2-year and 5-year fixed-rate mortgages   Term Average rate Weekly change Yearly change 2-year fixed 4.57% -0.05% -0.83% 5-year fixed 4.55% -0.04% -0.45%   Lowest rates for 2-year and 5-year fixed-rate mortgages   Term Lowest rate Weekly change Yearly change 2-year fixed 3.69% -0.13% -0.98% 5-year fixed 3.87% -0.01% -0.36%   Average…
Read More
Breaking News

Housing Insight Report Covering May 2025

Sales On average, there were around 11.5 homes placed for sale per member branch in May 2025. Lettings The average void period reported by member agents increased to just over three weeks in May 2025. We are seeing an average of 37% of housing transactions taking longer than 17 weeks to complete. The timescales are…
Read More
Breaking News

Rental Market Hotspots Drive National Growth

New analysis from FCC Paragon reveals modest national growth in rental demand across England in Q2 2025, up by 1.2% to 29.4%. However, this overall increase masks significant regional variation, with several counties experiencing substantial quarterly surges that are driving the market forward. The research shows that rental demand across England strengthened in Q2, up 1.2%…
Read More
Breaking News

Nationwide House Price Index for June 2025 – Thoughts from the Industry

Nationwide House Price Index for June 2025 shows House prices fell by -0.8% between May and June of this year. On an annual basis, the average house price increased by 2.1% although this rate of growth had slowed from 3.5% the previous month. As a result, the average UK house price now sits at £271,619.…
Read More
Breaking News

Clarity still needed on key areas in Renters’ Rights Bill

Ahead of Report Stage of the Renters’ Rights Bill in the House of Lords later today, 1 July 2025, Propertymark is urging the UK Government and Peers to amendment Bill, so it is fit for purpose. There remain long-standing concerns about the capacity and capability of the Courts, with the time from claim to hearing…
Read More
Cozy Pet Cat Tree Grey
Breaking News

Pet deposits only option following UK Government U-turn on Renters’ Rights Bill

Ahead of Report Stage of the Renters’ Rights Bill in the House of Lords which kicks off later today, Tuesday 1 July 2025, Propertymark is urging Peers to support an amendment that would allow for an additional pet deposit now that the UK Government has tabled amendments to remove pet insurance requirements. Since the introduction…
Read More