Help to Buy house prices have overheated by £63k

March 7, 2019

Help to Buy house prices have overheated by £63k & could leave FTBs in Government induced negative equity!

The latest research by for sale by owner website, www.OkayLah.com, has revealed how the Government’s Help to Buy scheme has hugely overheated and while the big house builders that have taken advantage of the scheme have made huge profits, a collapse could leave hundreds of thousands of homeowners in negative equity.

OkayLah.com looked at the number of Help to Buy completions each quarter since Q2 of 2013 and the total sold value of those Help to Buy properties to ascertain the price of the average Help to Buy property in each quarter. They then compared this to the average first-time buyer house price from the Land Registry to see how prices differed for those using the scheme.

In Q2 of 2013 when Help to Buy was introduced, the average first time buyer house price was £197,000, with the price paid per a Help to Buy property just £186,091, making them over £10,000 better off as a result of using the scheme.

But by Q3, this had fallen to just over £6,000 better off, with a complete turnaround coming by Q4 with the average Help to Buy house price exceeding that of the average first-time buyer by £7,714.

Fast forward to 2018 and a sector suffering from a lack of supply but bolstered by this huge spike in demand as a result of the Government’s ‘helping hand’ is now vastly out of kilter with the rest of the market.

Today the average first-time buyer house price is £236,000, however, those buying through the Help to Buy scheme are forking out a staggering £298,927 – a different of £62,927.

This deficit has been increasing each quarter and the now leaves many in danger of negative equity should the housing bubble burst and prices plummet.

Founder and CEO of www.OkayLah.com, Paul Telford, commented:

“It’s quite astonishing how out of shape the Help to Buy scheme now looks against the backdrop of the rest of first-time buyer market across the nation. While it was implemented with the best intentions and initially did serve as intended, the consequences of further fuelling demand in an area of the housing market that was already in desperate need of additional stock is plain to see.

What’s perhaps more alarming is that as much as half of the £1bn or so made by the nation’s biggest house builders has come from the Government subsidised scheme and essentially straight out of the pocket of taxpayers.

Not only has this pushed Help to Buy prices up massively, but it leaves those buying through the scheme on vary precarious ground. While we are unlikely to see a market crash despite the slowdown caused by Brexit uncertainty, a notable softening of property values would leave many in negative equity when considering their Help to Buy property within the wider landscape of the first-time buyer market climate.”

Quarter
Completions
Value of Equity Loans (£m) at completion1
Total value of properties sold (£m)2
Avg price paid per H2B property
Avg UK FTB House Price*
Help to Buy ‘Premium’ (£)
Help to Buy ‘Premium’ (%)
2013
14,023
566.15
2,840.37
Q2
2,103
78.09
391.35
£186,091
£197,000
(£10,909)
-6%
Q3
3,944
156.24
784.31
£198,862
£205,000
(£6,138)
-3%
Q4
7,976
331.82
1,664.70
£208,714
£201,000
£7,714
4%
2014
28,376
1,226.04
6,160.42
 
Q1
5,581
235.21
1,181.89
£211,770
£205,000
£6,770
3%
Q2
8,775
380.81
1,913.72
£218,088
£210,000
£8,088
4%
Q3
5,846
252.67
1,269.99
£217,241
£218,000
(£759)
0%
Q4
8,174
357.36
1,794.82
£219,577
£209,000
£10,577
5%
2015
31,827
1,469.26
7,399.13
 
Q1
4,929
215.84
1,085.28
£220,183
£212,000
£8,183
4%
Q2
9,355
429.76
2,163.86
£231,305
£212,000
£19,305
9%
Q3
6,898
319.26
1,608.46
£233,178
£219,000
£14,178
6%
Q4
10,645
504.4
2,541.54
£238,754
£217,000
£21,754
10%
2016
38,383
2,094.12
9,889.73
 
Q1
6,788
329.15
1,652.41
£243,431
£223,000
£20,431
9%
Q2
10,814
583.66
2,787.65
£257,782
£220,000
£37,782
17%
Q3
8,542
474.03
2,210.02
£258,724
£226,000
£32,724
14%
Q4
12,239
707.29
3,239.65
£264,699
£225,000
£39,699
18%
2017
46,300
2,911.44
12,995.36
 
Q1
8,212
504.31
2,226.81
£271,165
£221,000
£50,165
23%
Q2
13,863
870.61
3,884.48
£280,205
£228,000
£52,205
23%
Q3
10,233
659.66
2,921.47
£285,495
£229,000
£56,495
25%
Q4
13,992
876.86
3,962.60
£283,205
£225,000
£58,205
26%
2018
36,310
2,397.73
10,601.71
 
Q1
10,170
665.81
2,934.05
£288,500
£227,000
£61,500
27%
Q2
14,950
967.06
4,322.67
£289,142
£232,000
£57,142
25%
Q3
11,190
764.85
3,344.99
£298,927
£236,000
£62,927
27%

 

Properganda PR

National and local media coverage for property businesses. Journo quotes delivered in minutes.

You May Also Enjoy

Breaking News

Fledgling homeowners cut costs by taking on fixer-uppers to achieve dream home

66% of first-time buyers bought a cheaper home because it needed DIY or renovation work done Many choosing a ‘fixer-upper’ were able to buy in their preferred location, add value and put their stamp on it DIY almost mandatory among first-time buyers, with 93% completing at least one project since moving in But three quarters…
Read More →
Breaking News

House Price Index for April 2026 – Thoughts from the Indutry

The latest Halifax House Price Index for April 2026 shows that: – On a monthly basis, house prices remained largely static, down by just -0.1% between March and April 2026. Annually, house prices were up 0.4%, albeit this rate of annual growth had slowed from 0.8% the previous month. As a result, the average house…
Read More →
Breaking News

House prices remained broadly stable in April

• House prices edged down -0.1% in April, following a -0.5% fall in March • Average property price now £299,313, compared with £299,609 in March • Annual growth slowed to +0.4%, from +0.8% in March • Northern Ireland continues to record the strongest annual growth at +7.6%   Amanda Bryden, Head of Mortgages, Halifax, said:…
Read More →
Breaking News

Breaking Property News 7/5/26

Daily bite-sized proptech and property news in partnership with Proptech-X.   The Hidden Economics of AI Agents: Why Businesses May Spend More Than They Ever Did on SaaS AI agents are rapidly being positioned as the next evolution of enterprise software. The problem is that many companies are still evaluating them through a SaaS lens…
Read More →
Estate Agent Talk

£15m property market accounts for 0.04% of all homes

The latest analysis from AgentWise has found that while more than 30,000 homes are currently for sale across Great Britain with an asking price between £1m and £5m, properties priced above £1m account for just 6% of all available housing stock, with the market becoming dramatically smaller and increasingly relationship-led as values rise. With so…
Read More →
Home and Living

Beware of the underinsurance risk created by property alterations

Property owners are being warned that while alterations may well improve a building, they can also change its rebuild cost. Where works materially affect a building’s size, layout, specification or services, the amount it is insured for may need to be reviewed, as a matter of urgency, according to experts at RebuildCostASSESSMENT.com “It’s a common…
Read More →