Small Independent Estate Agency – A Question of the Survival of the Fittest?

Sadly, it would seem that we live in a world where at present being small and on the high street is currently out of fashion. Why has this view (particularly amongst the young) percolated in more recent times? I would strongly suspect that it has much to do with the way our general shopping habits have changed over the last ten years in particular. Our interaction with globalised household brands such as Apple, Starbucks, Amazon etc is now so commonplace that a good many of us wouldn’t naturally think to look elsewhere when we make many of our household and technological purchases.

If, for arguments sake, we accept the premise that being successful in today’s retail environment is all about low cost and convenience – why do so many niche retailers, farmer’s markets, independent restaurants and cafes and even specialist shops around the country not only survive, but in many cases thrive? I believe that there is still a place on our local high street for expert knowledge, personal service, quality, and even authenticity when interested in purchasing particular goods or services.

Perhaps fortunately for small independent estate agents in particular, I believe that the buying and selling of property is one of those areas, that still (in the great majority of cases) works better with competent and knowledgeable human interaction. That is not to say that smaller agents shouldn’t in addition, embrace technological advancement, particularly where it improves the customer experience or makes a business more accessible (out of office hours for example). But technology is only part of the answer, as it is undeniable that consumer attitudes and expectations are changing – particularly amongst the young, who will of course be the sellers, buyers, landlords and tenants of the future.

Anyway I digress, as whilst on the one hand I feel true conviction in quoting Mark Twain “the news of my death has been greatly exaggerated” when commenting to others about the long term future of independent estate agency, even I cannot deny the simple truth – that there are currently just too many estate agents for the amount of business in the UK that is available.

You see the facts speak for themselves, in that the Land Registry figures regarding the number of properties sold have shown a downward trend for some years now, and yet the number of estate agency offices has proportionately increased over the same period. A lack of “barriers to entry” such as mandatory licensing or qualification, coupled with rising house prices and an easing of high street planning restrictions, has made the present situation a self-fulfilling prophecy. In truth you really do not have to be the world’s greatest economist to understand what will happen next.

However, I believe that there is still hope for many small independent estate agents, as due to a shorter chain of command, they should (in theory at least) be able to react to local market conditions more speedily than their larger corporate counterparts – that is of course if they are minded to.

For what it is worth, I believe that the key to their long term survival can be summed up in one word, and that is – RELEVANCE. If we accept the premise that independent estate agency, when working at its best, is largely a localised business – then it needs to work harder to stay not only relevant to the local property market, but more importantly to its locality and local community too. That way it can persist, connected to the needs of local people, and can tailor or diversify its range of services accordingly.

In other words, make the most of being local by getting personally more involved in the local community as a whole – that way, maybe your future potential clients will start to finally recognise that not all estate agents are the same – particularly when they next come to buy, sell or let their property in the months and years ahead.

The author of this article is Peter Nicholls CEO of ideology consulting. For more information, go to www.ideologyconsulting.co.uk

Peter Nicholls

You May Also Enjoy

Breaking News

Rightmove celebrates 25 years of viral property moments

As Rightmove marks its 25th birthday, we’re celebrating the properties that stopped people mid-scroll, sparked thousands of shares, and became internet sensations. From a house with its own Tardis to a shark crashing through a roof, these homes prove that the UK property market is anything but ordinary. With billions of minutes spent on Rightmove…
Read More
Breaking News

Rental stock availability in England rises by 19.7%

The latest rental stock analysis from Adiuvo, the UK’s leading provider of 24/7 property management solutions, reveals that tenants in England are benefitting from a 19.7% increase in stock over the 12 months leading up to Q3 2025. In some areas of the country, annual stock growth easily exceeded 50%. Adiuvo has analysed rental listings…
Read More
Breaking News

Tenant demand continues to climb in Q3 as rental market shows no signs of cooling

The latest market analysis by Dwelly, one of the UK’s leading lettings acquisition and success planning experts, has revealed that tenant demand continued to climb across the rental sector during the third quarter of this year, with West Sussex home to the highest demand, whilst Rutland saw the largest quarterly increase. Dwelly’s Rental Demand Index* analyses…
Read More
Breaking News

Halifax House Price Index for September 2025 – Thoughts from the Industry

Halifax House Price Index for September 2025. The latest index shows that: On a monthly basis, house prices fell by -0.3% between August and September 2025. However, house prices were up 1.3% on an annual basis. The new average house price now sits at £298,184. Thoughts from the Industry. Nathan Emerson, CEO of Propertymark, comments:…
Read More
Breaking News

Halifax House Price Index for September 2025

House prices in September 2025 were -0.3% lower than the same month a year earlier. Average house price – £298,184 Monthly change -0.3% Quarterly change +0.4% Annual change +1.3%   Amanda Bryden, Head of Mortgages, Halifax, said: “The average UK house price edged down by -0.3% (£794) in September, following a modest rise in August.…
Read More
New Build for Merseyside
Breaking News

First-time buyer demand falls sharply

First-time buyer demand falls sharply across Britain’s major cities, with Nottingham leading the decline The latest research by Yopa has shown that first-time buyer demand has dropped significantly across a number of major British cities, with Nottingham seeing the sharpest decline since the start of the year. Yopa analysed first-time buyer (FTB) demand based on…
Read More