The Paradox of Choice.

Is too much choice is a bad thing?

It’s a strange concept to think that providing clients with a vast array services and options could actually be doing your business harm. Why would allowing your clients to choose from a variety of options be a bad thing? It seems a little counter-intuitive, but the more there is to choose from the less likely someone is to make a choice. This phenomenon is called the paradox of choice” and it’s something I experience every time I walk down the fabric softener isle. The most famous documentation of this though is the jam experiment.

If you’re unfamiliar with the experiment, I’ll give you a very quick break down. In an upscale supermarket two psychologists set up the jam section with 24 different jams then observed sales and consumer behaviour. They then replicated conditions but only provided 6 jams to choose from and what they saw was sales rocket 10 fold.

Credit to gifrific.com

There’s many different factors which result in this outcome, from overloading your potential customer with too many options, to the customer just not having the time to weigh up the different options. Regardless of why, the outcome is the same: having to many choices often results in customers not making a choice.

But I don’t sell jam…

This has been something widely observed across huge variety of industries, not just the retail and preserves isle. Everything from financial services to video games employ some observation of this.

World of Warcraft is one of the biggest online games in the world with more than 10 million active users logging in on a weekly basis. Everyone picks a character and there are hundreds of character customisation options, the race of your character, your class, sub class etc. But it all starts with one choice: What side do you want to fight for? This is a great example of restricting peoples’ choice without sacrificing depth, and it’s a very simple mentality to apply to your website.

A visitor landing on a cluttered home page with a huge amount of different options won’t take the time to read through all of them, they’ll just leave in favour of somewhere they can get what they want easier. It’s about guiding your user and finding a way to restrict initial choice without sacrificing depth. It’s getting that all important first click out of a user that takes them on the journey to where they need to be. All this can be boiled down to one simple choice: are you looking to buy or sell? That one choice can get your clients flying towards what they want and eliminate anything they don’t need to see, simple!

Leading by example

If you quickly go and have a look at our website as soon as you land you see a single sentence about us and 3 options in the middle. Yes, you can scroll down and see a little more but the initial impression is no clutter and nothing to slog through. A user knows what they want, and it’s clear how they should get there.

At Estate Apps we offer a huge range of services to the property industry, and reading through all of them can be a little tedious – Custom Websites, templates websites, responsive design, iOS apps, Android apps, dedicated mobile sites, branding services, video services, content writing services with a whole bunch of other services within each of those and even more in development. Can you imagine our homepage with a link for each of those? And even worse a full page of text dedicated to each? Ain’t nobody got time fo’ that! We’d be doing our competitors a favour by driving our own traffic elsewhere.

What does this mean for me?

When you’re thinking to yourself “I don’t get enough leads from my website” take a look at it from a user’s point of view, there might be a reason for that. Is it unclear? Is there too much text? Have you overloaded them with information? If the answer was even a maybe to any of those questions, it might be time to look at your website.

These are all easy design mistakes to make. It’s completely understandable that you want to talk about everything you do, and that’s fine! Just don’t overload your users with information, especially information they just don’t have time to deal with. If you think it’s about time you had a look at your website, or even just want to get some advice, get in touch. We’re always happy to help.

Alex Evans

You May Also Enjoy

Breaking News

Forget kerb appeal: LRG report reveals what really triggers a homebuyer’s offer

One of the UK’s largest property services groups has published its debut sales report, uncovering what genuinely persuades buyers to make an offer – and the findings challenge the traditional focus on kerb appeal. While sellers often guess which improvements will pay off, the data shows where money is well spent and where it’s wasted.…
Read More
Breaking News

Prime London’s love affair with period homes continues

One in four listings are historic properties The latest research from Jefferies London shows that nearly a quarter of homes listed for sale across prime central London (23.3%) offer high-end homebuyers the chance to secure a period property, with demand for prime period properties at its highest in Maida Vale. Jefferies London analysed current for…
Read More
Breaking News

Industry Response to latest Nationwide House Price Index

Nationwide House Price Index for October 2025, with the latest figures showing no Halloween haunting for homebuyers where house price growth is concerned – despite widespread talks of Autumn Budget uncertainty hitting the market. The latest index shows that: – House prices increased by 0.3% between September and October of this year. On an annual…
Read More
Breaking News

The capital’s most haunted property hotspots for Halloween homebuyers

The latest analysis by Foxtons has revealed which of the capital’s spookiest postcodes command the largest house price premiums, as the average cost of purchasing a property in one of London’s most haunted neighbourhoods comes in 48% more than the wider London average. Foxtons analysed the property market across 14 of London’s most haunted locations,…
Read More
Breaking News

Annual house price growth edges higher in October

Slight increase in annual house price growth to 2.4% House prices were up 0.3% month on month Kitchen and bathroom renovations most popular amongst homeowners in last five years Analysis based on Nationwide’s HPI data shows extensions or loft conversions with a bedroom can increase house value by up to 24% Headlines Oct-25 Sep-25 Monthly…
Read More
Breaking News

How much will a Halloween Castle set you back

The latest research from Enness Global has revealed that, for those looking to follow in the footsteps of Count Dracula this Halloween, the average castle on the UK market will set buyers back around £2.2 million, requiring a deposit of £332,609 and a monthly mortgage repayment of more than £10,000. Enness Global analysed current castle…
Read More