What’s causing landlords and tenants to fall out of love in your region? Rental dispute reasons revealed

February 20, 2020

The latest data by rental deposit replacement scheme, Ome, has revealed which areas of the UK have seen the biggest uplift in deposit disputes, as well as the areas with the highest number of total disputes raised.

Research shows that London is home to the highest proportion of rental disagreements between landlords and tenants when it comes to the return of a deposit, accounting for 37% of all cases in the last year.

The South East came second with 16% of all disputes, while the North West also accounted for double-figure disputes at 11%.

However, when it comes to the change in dispute figures year on year, it is Yorkshire and the Humber that tops the table, with a notable 28% increase in the number of rental deposit disagreements seen within the rental market.

The East of England has also seen one of the largest increases at 17%, with the capital ranking third, up 7% in the last year.

It’s not all negative though, with the East Midlands and South West seeing a decline in deposit disputes, down -2% annually, while the West Midlands saw an increase of just 1%.

Poor communication as to why a deposit was to be withheld was the most frequent cause for disputes across every region other than the South East. In the South East the cleanliness of a property at check-out was found to be the number one cause of a dispute.

Cleaning, poor communication and damage to a property ranked as the top three issues across all regions other than the East Midlands where general redecoration ranked third along with cleaning and deposits as the biggest cause of a dispute.

Across the board, disputes resulting from the lack of explanation for withholding the deposit has seen the largest annual increase, up 12% year on year, followed by disputes on missing items from the property (+10%) and damage to the property (6%).

However, disputes concerning holding onto the deposit due to rent arrears have seen a year on year decline of -8% which should be encouraging for landlords.

Co-founder of Ome, Matthew Hooker, commented:

“Deposit disputes have always been a bone of contention within the rental industry and despite the sector’s diverse makeup, they tend to focus on the same issues concerning outstanding payments, damage, cleanliness, and missing inventory wherever you are.

The introduction of formal dispute resolution has, at least, eased the burden from the courts and a standardised approach has raised standards in the sector. However, despite this rental deposits remain a friction point for many tenants and landlords.

This tends to be most prevalent within London where the sums being disputed are far higher than other regions but as the data shows, the number of cases fluctuates regionally and will continue to do so year to year.

Unfortunately, there’s no one solution that can fix all when it comes to deposit disputes and it’s imperative that the industry continues to deal with each dispute on a case by case basis with an impartial body regulating this practice.”

Ranking by disputes %
Disputes 2018-19
Region
All %
Annual Change
Yorkshire and the Humber
5%
28%
East of England
7%
17%
London
37%
7%
North West
11%
6%
North East
3%
5%
Wales
2%
3%
South East
16%
2%
West Midlands
6%
1%
South West
8%
-2%
East Midlands
5%
-2%
All
100%
6%
Dispute Type
Annual Change
Deposit held with no reason
12%
Missing Items
10%
Damage
6%
Redecoration
4%
Other
3%
Cleaning
0.8%
rent arrears
-8%
Yorkshire and the Humber
Dispute type
%
Deposit not returned – no reason given by landlord
39%
Cleaning
20%
Damage to property
15%
General redecoration
12%
Other deductions
8%
Missing / replacement items
3%
Rent arrears / outstanding bills
2%
East of England
Dispute type
%
Deposit not returned – no reason given by landlord
26%
Cleaning
25%
Damage to property
20%
General redecoration
16%
Other deductions
7%
Missing / replacement items
4%
Rent arrears / outstanding bills
2%
London
Dispute type
%
Deposit not returned – no reason given by landlord
30%
Damage to property
21%
Cleaning
18%
General redecoration
12%
Other deductions
11%
Missing / replacement items
5%
Rent arrears / outstanding bills
3%
North West
Dispute type
%
Deposit not returned – no reason given by landlord
35%
Cleaning
22%
Damage to property
16%
General redecoration
12%
Other deductions
8%
Missing / replacement items
4%
Rent arrears / outstanding bills
3%
North East
Dispute type
%
Deposit not returned – no reason given by landlord
36%
Cleaning
21%
Damage to property
16%
General redecoration
12%
Other deductions
7%
Missing / replacement items
4%
Rent arrears / outstanding bills
3%
Wales
Dispute type
%
Deposit not returned – no reason given by landlord
30%
Cleaning
28%
Damage to property
16%
General redecoration
11%
Other deductions
10%
Missing / replacement items
3%
Rent arrears / outstanding bills
2%
South East
Dispute type
%
Cleaning
30%
Deposit not returned – no reason given by landlord
24%
Damage to property
17%
General redecoration
14%
Other deductions
9%
Missing / replacement items
3%
Rent arrears / outstanding bills
3%
West Midlands
Dispute type
%
Deposit not returned – no reason given by landlord
38%
Cleaning
21%
Damage to property
16%
General redecoration
10%
Other deductions
9%
Rent arrears / outstanding bills
3%
Missing / replacement items
2%
South West
Dispute type
%
Deposit not returned – no reason given by landlord
28%
Cleaning
27%
Damage to property
16%
General redecoration
16%
Other deductions
6%
Missing / replacement items
4%
Rent arrears / outstanding bills
4%
East Midlands
Dispute type
%
Deposit not returned – no reason given by landlord
32%
Cleaning
25%
General redecoration
15%
Damage to property
14%
Other deductions
8%
Missing / replacement items
3%
Rent arrears / outstanding bills
3%

Properganda PR

National and local media coverage for property businesses. Journo quotes delivered in minutes.

You May Also Enjoy

Estate Agent Talk

Buy-to-Let Explained: How It Works and Is It Worth It?

Buy-to-let is one of the most popular property investment strategies in the UK, attracting investors who want to generate regular rental income while benefiting from long-term property value growth. Whether you are a first-time landlord or someone considering adding property to an existing investment portfolio, understanding how buy-to-let works is essential. If you are exploring opportunities with Whitegates…
Read More →
Letting Agent Talk

The Hidden Cost of Deposit Disputes for Letting Agents

Nobody gets into lettings because they love arguing over oven grease. Yet for a growing number of letting agents across London and beyond, deposit disputes at the end of a tenancy have become one of the most quietly destructive parts of the job — eating into time, draining morale, and slowly eroding the trust that…
Read More →
Breaking News

Britain’s strongest housing markets revealed

The latest research from Benham and Reeves reveals the best-performing housing markets across Great Britain when it comes to the average rate of house price growth seen over the course of 2025, with the northern regions and Scotland outperforming most of the rest of the country with annual price growth of up to 11%. Last…
Read More →
Rightmove logo
Breaking News

Over £900 million economic opportunity lost to property fall throughs

Analysis from the UK’s largest property platform Rightmove reveals there is an economic opportunity of over £900 million in England if the number of property transactions falling through can be reduced The calculations show that nearly £392m in potential estate agency revenue and £515m in potential government stamp duty receipts were lost last year to…
Read More →
Breaking News

Landlords chasing rental arrears of £470m

The latest research from Propoly – the platform that automates compliance, reduces risk and protects landlords – has revealed that landlords in England deal with more than £470 million worth of rent arrears in a year, with the largest number of tenants in arrears found in London and the North East. Propoly has analysed the…
Read More →
Estate Agent Talk

Building Buyer Trust Through Architectural Visualization in Real Estate Marketing

In real estate marketing, trust is not a soft value. It is a transaction driver. Buyers commit to years of financial exposure based on how credible a project feels long before it is built. That credibility is no longer shaped by brochures alone. Today, developers often work with a rendering agency to construct a visual…
Read More →