Simple Landlords Insurance reveals top reasons for buy-to-let insurance claims

Storm damage, burst pipes and damage from break-ins were the top reasons that buy-to-let property investors made an insurance claim, new figures released today by Simple Landlords Insurance reveal. These findings highlight why landlords should take insurance seriously to protect their investments

Simple analysed data from over 100,000 policies to compile the data on the most common risks faced by landlords.

The most common claim was for storm damage, which cost an average of £1,500 to repair. Next was damage to ceilings, walls and carpets caused by burst pipe with an average £4,500 repair bill. The third most common reason for making a claim was property damage caused by burglars with an average claim of £2,300.

The most expensive claim in the top 10 is £25,000 to repair the damage caused by an electrical fire.

The findings are included in Simple Landlords Insurance Risk Report, published today (url: www.simplelandlordsinsurance.com/risk-report). The report includes practical tips to reduce the likelihood of having to make a claim.

Andrew Weston from Simple Landlords Insurance says: “We have released this research to show the practical measures landlords can take to avoid the hassle and time of making an insurance claim, all of which will help keep premiums low.

“Saving money will become even more important for landlords in coming years as tax increases announced by the Chancellor are phased in, which for many investors could make the difference between profit and loss.”

The report also explains how insurance premiums can vary significantly according to property type, location, and tenant type.

Weston continues: “Buying insurance is often one of the last things buy-to-let investors consider. Having a clear understanding of the key factors that can influence your premium will save landlords money in the long run.”

The Risk Report warns landlords about damages that are not covered by insurance policies. The most common reason that a landlord did not have cover was that they hadn’t purchased accidental damage cover in their policy.

Here are Simple Landlords Insurance five top tips for landlords:

  1. Conduct regular inspections to make sure your tenants are who they claim to be
  2. Make friends with the neighbours so that they will tell you if something goes awry at your property
  3. Consider taking out extra insurance to reduce your excess payments and to cover accidental damage
  4. Use the BCIS calculator to find an accurate rebuild cost
  5. Keep your roof well maintained and gutters clear to avoid weather damage

Top 10 reasons that landlords make an insurance claim

 

  The damage Average repair cost
1 Storm damage £1,500
2 Burst pipe £4,500
3 Damage from break ins £2,300
4 Vandalism £1,900
5 Accidental damage to the building £2,200
6 Excessive rain £2,100
7 Collapsed drains £2,600
8 Vehicle crashing into the property £4,600
9 Electrical fire £25,000
10 Leak from the Property £2,000
 

Average

£4,600

 

 

Case studies

Storm damage

While you never know where a storm will hit, certain features can make properties particularly vulnerable to harsh weather conditions. Properties with conservatories attached and dormer windows are especially likely to be damaged by high winds and excessive rain during a storm.

A property in Edinburgh needed more than £11,000 worth of repairs, including Perspex roof covering to the buildings’ exterior and solid oak flooring to its interior, after two panels from its conservatory roof were ripped off during high winds in January 2015.

In Keighley, West Yorkshire, another landlord sustained damage worth just under £5,000 when their conservatory roof was replaced after every single roof pane was punctured by hailstones during a storm in July 2015.

Forced entry

A landlord in the West Midlands was contacted by his student tenants following a break in. The burglars smashed through the back door and tried to enter all the bedrooms upstairs. All the doors were locked but the thieves damaged the doors and frames, a damage bill of £4,931.52.

Alex Evans

You May Also Enjoy

Breaking News

What renters and landlords need to know ahead of major rental law changes

With just one month to go until the first phase of the Renters’ Rights Act comes into force, the leading professional body, Propertymark, is urging renters and landlords across England to understand how the changes could affect them. From 1 May 2026, the legislation will introduce some of the biggest changes to the private rented…
Read More
Estate Agent Talk

Tackling Empty Properties

A UK Perspective on Best Practice and Recommendations for Reform Propertymark, the UK’s leading professional body for property agents, has today published a comprehensive new position paper highlighting the urgent need for coordinated, practical and properly resourced action to bring long-term empty properties back into use. With over 359,000 homes sitting empty for more than…
Read More
Breaking News

Pet-friendly rentals plunge 39%

New research from Inventory Base reveals that the number of pet-friendly rental homes in England has fallen by -39% since the start of 2026, as landlords appear to be reducing the number of homes openly marketed as allowing pets ahead of the Renters’ Rights Act taking effect from 1st May. The Renters’ Rights Act (RRA)…
Read More
Breaking News

Latest Nationwide house price data showing a 2.2% increase

Industry reaction to Nationwide house price data showing UK annual house price growth picked up to 2.2% in March, from 1.0% in February. Nathan Emerson, CEO of Propertymark, comments: “An uplift in house prices will be welcomed by the market and suggests that buyer demand remains resilient despite ongoing economic headwinds. Improved sentiment, coupled with…
Read More
Breaking News

UK house price growth picks up in March

UK annual house price growth picked up to 2.2% in March, from 1.0% in February Northern Ireland best performing area in Q1 2026, with prices up 9.5% year-on-year Outer South East weakest performing region, with prices down 0.7% compared with Q1 2025 Headlines Mar-26 Feb-26 Monthly Index* 552.6 547.7 Monthly Change* 0.9% 0.3% Annual Change…
Read More
Breaking News

Mortgage approvals up in February

The latest mortgage approval data from the Bank of England show that: –   Mortgage approvals on house purchases for February sat at 62,584 up (3.9%) from 60,246 seen in January. Approvals are down (-3.9%) when compared to the 65,114 seen in February 2025. This annual decline was expected due to wider market slowdown and economic…
Read More