Westminster Council Embraces the Worst Aspects of NIMBYism
January 3, 2025
In May 2025, Westminster Council will seek to ban ‘For Sale’ signage across the borough, adding to the growing list of localist powers that are being misused by councils through tacit nods to NIMBYism and the creation of new revenue streams.
Misuse of Localism Powers
Abuse of ‘localism’ powers is not uncommon. In 2024, the National Federation of Builders (NFB) highlighted opposition to homes because no dog-walking routes were offered. This issue was resolved through a chargeable planning condition to provide dog walking route maps to new build occupants.
In another case, planners requested apple trees to be planted, only to force a change of decision, in case the fruit was either used as a projectile or be left to rot so becoming a slipping hazard.
In 2023, the NFB wrote a piece titled “No houses, no roads, no pizza, and definitely no ice cream!”, which highlighted how several local planning policies had strongly entwined localism with NIMBYism and demonstrated how localism has now extended its tentacles into shaping local people’s lifestyle choices and how local business should operate.
Westminster knows ‘best’
Under Article 7 of the Town and Country Planning Regulations 2007, Westminster Council already has a ban on ‘For Sale’ signage in some conservation areas, and so to ensure there is not a ‘two tier’ system, it is no seeking to expand this ban to the entire borough while ensuring the rules remain indefinite, so they do not have to revisit the decision for another fifteen years.
The proposal cites ‘substantial harm to visual amenity and local character,’ abuse of deemed consent rules’ and meeting their ‘Fairer Westminster’ objectives as the main reasoning. Additionally referencing climate change – due to the carbon impacts of producing signs – and the growth of online advertising as further grounds.
However, it is clear to see that Westminster Council’s arguments don’t hold water:
- Unauthorised ‘For Sale’ boards have decreased dramatically from 511 in 2013 to just 18 in 2023. Since 2021, 21 violations have been resolved informally.
- Although some estate agents will list their entire stock on online platforms such as ‘Rightmove,’ most do not because of the high costs, and some do not use them at all.
- Boards not only highlight that a property is available for sale, which in some areas can be rarity, but serves to advertise locally employing businesses.
- Unlike large agents and their franchisees, small local estate agents struggle to afford local premises across boroughs, and so rely on signage to advertise both their properties and their businesses.
- ‘For Sale’ board are re-used, and estate agents we spoke to told us the existing ban meant they changed their advertising practices to more leaflet drops, a practice which not only uses a far higher amount of paper, energy, and plastic but sees thousands of tonnes of paper immediately thrown away.
- Councils have begun setting local design codes for shop frontages to ensure they are ‘in keeping with local character,’ yet despite having ‘Advertising Design Guidelines,’ Westminster Council has not proposed to extend that to ‘For Sale’ signs.
On revenue raising, the fee for advertising planning permissions can range between £235 and £648, and with the Government proposing that councils set their own planning fees, one should not be surprised if councils use advertising of ‘For Sale’ signs to raise revenues as well as instil NIMBY sentiments.
This is certainly the case for ‘planning conditions’ on builds, which are meant to tackle certain local issues or requirements, such as acceptable brick colours or landscaping, Yet when planning applications already include that information, an individually chargeable planning condition will still be included, with any modifications to satisfy the changing winds often accruing a subsequent fee.
It is time to call out Westminster Council as NIMBY’s on this issue. They have not sought any ‘in character’ solution. Cite climate change as a concern, but their proposal will see increased energy use, more waste and reduced re-useable materials. Their whole premise will curtail local businesses by increasing all their costs, and consequently giving a leg up to big companies.
Westminster Council talk about tackling ‘Fairness’ and the two-tier system, but the borough’s housing crisis paints a different picture. The average house price is £960,000. More than 4,000 people are on its council housing waiting list, with 23 families waiting over two decades. 2,204 people have been stuck in temporary accommodation for at least ten years.
Meanwhile, the council is sitting on more than £185 million of unspent Section 106 funding, £129 million of which is allocated for affordable housing.
Test for the Government
As Secretary of State for Housing, Communities, and Local Government, Rt Hon Angela Rayner Secretary would decide whether the ‘For Sale’ ban is extended, and to her credit, she has taken a firm stance on opposing localist abuse.
However, if this Westminster Council proposal does land at her desk, it will be a litmus test of whether Labour is serious about growth because it understands the damaging nature of NIMBY decision making on the long tail of business. Or, whether its plan is to continue presenting itself as YIMBY champions by approving schemes which already met regulations but need a little help to overcome NIMBY hurdles.
You May Also Enjoy
Propertymark backs move to commonhold
Propertymark has welcomed proposals from the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government to phase out the sale of new leasehold flats in England and Wales, while warning that the transition to commonhold must be carefully managed to avoid market disruption and consumer confusion. Responding to the UK Government’s consultation on “Moving to commonhold: banning…
Read More 
Phasing out leasehold flats is the right thing to do
Propertymark has welcomed UK Government proposals to ban the sale of new leasehold flats and replace them with a commonhold system designed to give homeowners greater control over their properties. Responding to a consultation launched by the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, Propertymark said the reforms could help tackle many of the long-standing…
Read More 
Deposit Disputes Are Rising – Are Baths to Blame?
Interior Designers Say Acrylic Baths Are the Hidden Culprit in Family Rentals Deposit disputes over bathroom damage are rising, and acrylic bath surfaces are the overlooked culprit. Acrylic baths are often marketed as lasting 10 to 15 years or more, yet designers say many start to look tired in busy family homes within just a…
Read More 
Inheritance tax haul grows as more families are dragged into the tax net
Inheritance tax receipts got off to a slightly slower start in the first month of the 2026/27 tax year, but the figures still underline how rapidly the tax burden on estates continues to grow. HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) collected £0.7 billion in inheritance tax in April, £65 million less than during the same month…
Read More 
The 10 biggest homebuyer turn-offs
From overgrown gardens to nightmare neighbours, homeowners across Britain could be knocking tens of thousands of pounds off the value of their property before a buyer even makes an offer. New insight from House Buyer Bureau reveals the most common homebuyer turn-offs that could be thwarting your chances of making a sale, and the…
Read More 
5 trends driving London’s landscaped gardens
London gardens can add more than £205,000 in value as Chelsea tops table for prime buyers seeking outdoor space Ahead of this year’s Chelsea Flower Show, research by Enness Global has revealed that a garden can add more than £205,000 to the value of a London home, whilst Chelsea fittingly boasts the highest degree of…
Read More