How to weigh up a potential property investment – Rental Yield Vs Return on Capital Invested.

How to weigh up a potential property investment

When you register with your local estate agents for a potential investment purchase, it won’t take long before you are asked “what yield are you looking for?”.  Traditionally this measure has been used to assess the potential return provided by an investment and is calculated by taking the annual rental income, divided by the property purchase price, for example:

Purchase Price: £250,000 Monthly Rent: £1000pcm
Rental Yield: £1000pcm x 12 months / £250,000 = 4.8%

In the above example, you might think that as long as a return of 4.8% is more than you could achieve by simply putting your cash into a savings account, then you are better off investing in property?  Right?  Well it’s not quite that simple…

The calculation explained above assumes that you are buying the property with cash that would otherwise be in your bank account, however if you are financing the purchase with a buy-to-let mortgage, then you may only be putting a quarter of the purchase price down as a deposit.  Furthermore, any other expenditure, such as repairs and maintenance, is ignored entirely.

So is there a better way to assess the viability of a potential rental investment?  We believe so.

Return on Capital Invested (ROCI)

This method of assessing a rental investment takes into account the pre-tax profit (rent – expenses) as a percentage of the amount of capital (e.g. cash deposit) that you are going to have tied up in the investment, for example:

Purchase Price: £250,000
25% Deposit: £62,500
75% LTV Mortgage: £187,500
Purchase Costs: £4,000 (Stamp Duty; Solicitors)
Total Capital Invested = £62,500 Deposit + £4,000 Purchase Costs = £66,500
Monthly Rent: £1000pcm
Monthly Mortgage Interest (with a mortgage rate of 4%): £625
Monthly Service Charges, Repairs & Maintenance: £175
Monthly Profit = £1000 – £625 – £175 = £200pcm
Return on Capital Invested (ROCI) = £200pcm profit x 12 months / £66,500 = 3.61%

As the above example demonstrates, the actual return on the capital invested is much lower than the ‘rental yield’ calculation would suggest.  This example is even more shocking when you look at how the ROCI shifts if the mortgage rate went from 4% to 5%.  After a quick re-run of the calculation, at a 5% mortgage rate, the ROCI drops to below 0.8%.

The moral of the story – if you are buying an investment property with mortgage finance take the time to calculate the ROCI, otherwise you may find out that the monthly income you were promised by the eager estate agent disappears into thin air.

Alex Evans

You May Also Enjoy

Estate Agent Talk

Essential Garage Storage Solutions for Small Spaces

Maximize your garage space with practical storage ideas that keep your items organized and accessible. If you’re dealing with a smaller garage, smart solutions can make a big difference in keeping your space neat and usable. 1.  Wall-Mounted Storage Wall-mounted storage is an excellent way to save space and keep your garage organized, especially in…
Read More
Home and Living

How to Protect Your Property from Flooding and Water Damage

Flooding and water leaks can cause significant damage to your home or office. However, many issues can be prevented by taking proactive measures to protect your property. In this article, we’ll explain how to minimize risks and prepare for potential water-related threats. 1. Inspect and Maintain Your Plumbing System One of the most common causes…
Read More
Breaking News

ONS House Price Index – November 2024

Headlines Average UK private rents increased by 8.7% in the 12 months to October 2024 (provisional estimate); this is up from 8.4% in the 12 months to September 2024. Average rents increased to £1,348 (8.8%) in England, £766 (7.9%) in Wales, and £976 (6.6%) in Scotland, in the 12 months to October 2024. In Northern…
Read More
Breaking News

Foxtons Lettings Market Index October 2024

Headlines October saw the highest level of new stock entering the market, with an 8% increase from last year, the highest increase in four years October’s demand is marginally lower than last October and decreased 32% from September, as expected during this time of year Following a yearly high of £593 per week this September,…
Read More
Breaking News

Breaking Property News 20/11/24

Daily bite-sized proptech and property news in partnership with Proptech-X.   Proptech powered lettings service for BTR developers needing pre-approved, quality tenants at speed gets funding A proptech-driven letting agent has secured close to £500,000 during its first equity investment raise. Property Sense, headquartered in Stockport but operating nationally, secured the half a million pounds in…
Read More
Kerb appeal
Estate Agent Talk

Why November and December are the best and most affordable months to buy

Buyers and sellers looking for the right time to move can consider top reasons from property experts to start the process this November and December. The autumn and winter months may not be the first that come to mind when considering a move, but potential buyers and sellers can be reassured by the experts that…
Read More